American Gods: Mixed opinions

Readers’ average rating:

Reposting to include Rebecca’s new review.

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsfantasy book review Neil Gaiman American GodsAmerican Gods by Neil Gaiman

This is a bad land for Gods… The old gods are ignored. The new gods are as quickly taken up as they are abandoned, cast aside for the next big thing. Either you’ve been forgotten, or you’re scared you’re going to be rendered obsolete, or maybe you’re just getting tired of existing on the whims of people.

Shadow, just out of prison and with nothing to go home to, is hired to be Mr. Wednesday’s bodyguard as he travels around America to warn all the other incarnations of gods, legends, and myths, that “a storm is coming.” There’s going to be a battle between the old gods who were brought to melting pot America by their faithful followers generations ago, and the new gods of technology, convenience, and individuality.

That’s the premise of Neil Gaiman‘s American Gods and it’s just crackling with promise! But unfortunately, that’s not really what this novel is about. It’s what the novel keeps telling us it’s about (and what many critics told us it was about), but it doesn’t deliver.

Yes, there are plenty of gods, myths, and legends, and Gaiman does great things with some of them (e.g., Ibis the undertaker and Mr. Nancy) but most are never developed and a reader who has not read an encyclopedia of folklore probably won’t catch all the clever allusions.

Yes, there’s Neil Gaiman’s characteristic style, which I always enjoy. His prose is clean, unvarnished, and exquisite. His characters are recognizable; His America is recognizable. In fact, this was the best part of the book (and what Gaiman does so well) — Shadow’s roadtrip across the United States gave Gaiman plenty of opportunities to showcase his humorous insights into the human condition and, in this case, small-town American life. This was lovely, and I enjoyed these parts of the book.

The problem with American Gods was that the plot, meandering this way and that across the continent, never solidified. Shadow goes to this American town, meets a few gods and legends, goes to this other place, meets a couple more… There are numerous short stories detailing the lives of these gods and the people who worshipped them, so we expect to see some of these folks again (perhaps at this coming battle), but we don’t. A few weird mystical things happen to Shadow and we anticipate an explanation for those occurrences. Then there’s a sub-plot involving Shadow’s undead wife who asks Shadow to bring her back to life.

I don’t want to ruin it for anybody, but let me say that the “storm” we’re promised doesn’t materialize. Every time there’s a conflict, or a tight spot, someone suddenly shows up and, knowingly or unknowingly, takes care of it. Shadow (and his dead wife) figure out what the bad guys are going to do before they do it. Characters who we hoped might play a bigger role, and events that seemed to be significant, just fade away. The whole thing kind of fizzles. The plot twists at the end aren’t clever or inventive — they just seem to be there to fit the role of “obligatory plot twist.”

The premise of American Gods has so much promise. I was anticipating some poignant social commentary on America and our habits of worship. After all, American Gods is a best-selling award-winning novel and I expect great things from Neil Gaiman. But it didn’t happen this time and I really can’t explain the critical acclaim for this novel.fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviews

~Kat Hooper


fantasy book review Neil Gaiman American GodsSince I tend to highlight older, lesser-known SFF authors that deserve more attention, that may be one reason I didn’t read Neil Gaiman’s work until recently. Nonetheless, Gaiman has a huge and enthusiastic following, so I figured there must be good reason for that. As it turns out, I really enjoyed his SANDMAN comic series as well as his books The Graveyard Book, Stardust, and The Ocean at the End of the Lane. However, having saved his adult-themed full-length novels for last, I find that I’ve liked them the least. Specifically, Neverwhere just seemed to go nowhere (see what I did there?) despite a magical London setting, and now American Gods, a book showered with awards and accolades.

I won’t describe the plot in detail since Kat’s review does an admirable job of that. In fact, I think my reaction to American Gods was almost identical to hers. The conceit that all gods old and new rise and fall depending on the number and intensity of their followers is neat. Setting that on a road trip across small-town middle America is even more enticing, and constantly hinting that an epic battle of old and new gods is brewing builds a lot of anticipation on the readers’ part.

But what we actually get is a very meandering story that introduces dozens of characters representing old gods from a host of different mythologies, including Norse, Egyptian, Afro-Caribbean, Germanic, Native American, and others. Despite all these enticing ingredients, the final dish just didn’t deliver. In particular, the main character Shadow is a bit of a cipher, a brooding and melancholy ex-con who comes out of jail only to discover his wife recently died in a car crash. Cut adrift, he reluctantly accepts the offer to be bodyguard and muscle for a shifty old grifter named Mr. Wednesday. This provides the vehicle for Englishman Gaiman to explore a series of small-town settings and characters and explore the heart of America. As others have observed, he does a pretty good job capturing this essence, both the fundamental decency of folks and also the deteriorating economic conditions that face many small towns.

What American Gods is really lacking is a forward-moving plot to build momentum from these side-trip adventures as Mr. Wednesday visits a series of his allies and cronies while committing grifts and cons along the way, something I think Gaiman feels is a very American tradition. It seems like Shadow is forever getting caught and facing death only to be saved at the eleventh hour by another ‘deus ex plotica’ (my own invention), and then hopping back in the car for the next encounter. We of course learn the overarching plot in the closing acts, and it gives more coherence to the actions of Mr. Wednesday and his cronies, but for some reason it didn’t click and make me stand up and say “Yes, now it all makes sense!”

Another aspect that just didn’t work for me was the surprisingly explicit sex and steady stream of profanity. Perhaps I’ve been used to his YA books like The Graveyard Book and Stardust, but I didn’t see what this really added to the story. I almost felt that he deliberately ratcheted this up to give the book a more ‘gritty Americana’ feel. That might work for a book dedicated to the dark underbelly of America like the books of James Ellroy, but it didn’t seem to fit for his story of old and new gods lurking in the shadows of middle America.

I listened to the 10th Anniversary full-cast audiobook edition of American Gods, which includes 12,000 additional words and is the author’s preferred text. The various voice actors do yeoman work and even Gaiman himself adds some narration and his voice is very charming. I just wish it were in the service of a better story.

I’ve heard a lot of divided opinion about American Gods — some readers love it and consider it Gaiman’s best book, and others are less enthusiastic like me. Some have suggested that his most iconic work is his 76-volume SANDMAN comic epic, and I would definitely agree with that. In any case, even a lesser Gaiman book is worth reading, so I will leave it to you to decide.

~Stuart Starosta


American Gods by Neil Gaimanfantasy book review Neil Gaiman American GodsNeil Gaiman‘s own introduction describes this book as: “big and odd and meandering” and in his postscript as: “a thriller, and a murder mystery, and a romance, and a road trip.” Suffice to say that you’ll be getting a quite an eclectic mix of genres, tones, characters and themes when you crack open American Gods.

Only days before his release from prison, introverted and taciturn Shadow gets the news that his wife Laura has died in a car accident. Numb with grief, he boards a plane heading for home, only to get a job offer from a man calling himself Mr Wednesday. The deal is simple: Shadow acts as a driver, bodyguard and gofer as Mr Wednesday goes about his mysterious business — what that might be isn’t entirely clear, but Shadow is an observant man, and the puzzle pieces are gradually put together…

I don’t want to say too much more about the plot, as for a long time it’s deliberately kept ambiguous as to what exactly Mr Wednesday is doing. Like Shadow, the reader can only pay attention as best she/he can, and appreciate all the sights and sounds that the fantasy road trip offers them. Along with completely original people and places, Gaiman also incorporates real American landmarks such as Rock City and the House on the Rock (though describes them in such a way that makes you question their existence!).

To be honest, it took me a while to get into American Gods. It starts off pretty slowly, and for the longest time you have no idea what’s going on. There are chapters and passages that seem rather meaningless, and it’s not until the book’s halfway point that things start to make sense: characters’ motivations become clear; disparate plot-lines start getting woven together.

But one thing became clear as I made my way through the book — to enjoy the novel to its full extent you just HAVE to have a fairly thorough grasp of ancient mythology and the various pantheons of gods. Half the fun is getting a description of a new character’s appearance, personality and traits, and figuring out which of the ancient gods they really are. (An old man with one eye? With an affinity for Wednesday? I know who this is!) Though Gaiman eventually identifies each god explicitly, that still won’t mean much if you have no context for them.

It’s also jam-packed with other references, from Herodotus to The Beatles to obscure Scottish fairy tales collected by Joseph Jacobs. This is a book where Shadow can tell a raven to say “nevermore” without any explanation, so expect a lot of sneaky allusions to go over your head, as I’m sure many of them did with me.

As it happens, there are several editions of the novel floating around, and my recommendation is that you read the one published as “the author’s preferred text”. It contains about twelve thousand more words that the original edition, and comes with supplementary material such as reading group questions, an interview with the author, and “The Monarch of the Glen”, a novella that details another of Shadow’s adventures with the ancient gods.

American Gods is a deep and complex novel, one that’s soon to be adapted for television, which was part of the impetus for me reading it in the first place. In many ways it’s vintage Gaiman, specifically in his technique of updating old myths into contemporary settings, reforming them into something fresh but familiar. More than that, it’s a story of America’s identity, as explored by a (relatively) recent immigrant, and the thousands of contradictory components that make up its whole.

~Rebecca Fisher

American Gods — (2000) Publisher: After three years in prison, Shadow has done his time. But as the days, then the hours, then the hours, then the seconds until his release tick away, he can feel a storm building. Two days before he gets out, his wife Laura dies in a mysterious car crash, in apparently adulterous circumstances. Dazed, Shadow travels home, only to encounter the bizarre Mr Wednesday claiming to be a refugee from a distant war, a former god and the king of America. Together they embark on a very strange journey across the States, along the way solving the murders which have occurred every winter in one small American town. But they are being pursued by someone with whom Shadow must make his peace… Disturbing,gripping and profoundly strange, Neil Gaiman’s epic new novel sees him on the road to finding the soul of America.

SHARE:  Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail  FOLLOW:  Facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinrsstumblr
If you plan to buy this book, you can support FanLit by clicking on the book cover above and buying it (and anything else) at Amazon. It costs you nothing extra, but Amazon pays us a small referral fee. Click any book cover or this link. We use this income to keep the site running. It pays for website hosting, postage for giveaways, and bookmarks and t-shirts. Thank you!

KAT HOOPER, who started this site in June 2007, earned a Ph.D. in neuroscience and psychology at Indiana University (Bloomington) and now teaches at the University of North Florida. When she reads fiction, she wants to encounter new ideas and lots of imagination. She wants to view the world in a different way. She wants to have her mind blown. She loves beautiful language and has no patience for dull prose, vapid romance, or cheesy dialogue. She prefers complex characterization, intriguing plots, and plenty of action. Favorite authors are Jack Vance, Robin Hobb, Kage Baker, William Gibson, Gene Wolfe, Richard Matheson, and C.S. Lewis.

View all posts by

STUART STAROSTA, on our staff since March 2015, is a lifelong SFF reader who makes his living reviewing English translations of Japanese equity research. Despite growing up in beautiful Hawaii, he spent most of his time reading as many SFF books as possible. After getting an MA in Japanese-English translation in Monterey, CA, he has lived in Tokyo, Japan for the last 10 years with his wife, daughter, and dog named Lani. Stuart's reading goal is to fill in all the gaps in his reading of classic SF novels and Hugo/Nebula winners, as well as David Pringle's 100 Best SF and Fantasy Novels, before moving back to reading newer books. His favorite authors include Philip K Dick, China Mieville, Iain M. Banks, J.G. Ballard, Lucius Shepard, Neal Stephenson, Kurt Vonnegut, George R.R. Martin, Neil Gaiman, Robert Silverberg, Roger Zelazny, Ursula K. LeGuin, Guy Gavriel Kay, Walter Jon Williams, N.K. Jemisin, Arthur C. Clarke, H.G. Wells, Olaf Stapledon, J.R.R. Tolkien, Mervyn Peake, etc.

View all posts by

REBECCA FISHER, with us since January 2008, earned a Masters degree in literature at the University of Canterbury in New Zealand. Her thesis included a comparison of how C.S. Lewis and Philip Pullman each use the idea of mankind’s Fall from Grace to structure the worldviews presented in their fantasy series. Rebecca is a firm believer that fantasy books written for children can be just as meaningful, well-written and enjoyable as those for adults, and in some cases, even more so. Rebecca lives in New Zealand. She is the winner of the 2015 Sir Julius Vogel Award for Best SFF Fan Writer.

View all posts by

Review this book and/or Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Add your own review

Rating