The Seven Songs: Missing the X factor

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsfantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsThe Seven Songs by T.A. Barron

“Pursue the Seven Songs in Turn; the Parts Beget the Whole…”

The second book in T.A. Barron’s MERLIN SAGA (preceded by The Lost Years and followed by The Raging Fires) continues young Merlin’s journey toward the powerful wizard of legend. Having noticed that there was very little literature that dealt with Merlin in his formative years, Barron set about writing a “prequel” of sorts to Arthurian legend that explored what Merlin was like as a child. In the first book Merlin discovers the identity of his parents and travels to his homeland Fincayra, an island that exists between the mortal and spirit world.

Having found several treasures that have the power to restore life to Fincayra, Merlin begins his next adventure by travelling across the island with the Flowering Harp, bringing the dead landscape back to life with its music. Yet Merlin is distracted from his task by thoughts of his mother. Having abandoned her in Gwynedd (Wales) in order to discover his roots, he now longs for the chance to see her again. Using ill-advised magic to bring her to the island, their happiness is short-lived when she falls under a spell cast by the evil Rhita Gawr. Now Merlin must travail Fincayra in search of the Seven Songs of Wisdom that will grant him enough power to restore her to health.

With only a short span of time in which to complete this mission, Merlin must prove to be a quick student if he’s to save his mother’s life. Helped by his young friend Rhia (who has a secret of her own) as well as characters both old and new, he accumulates wisdom along with his experiences, knowing that a dangerous one-eyed ogre is waiting for him at the completion of his task.

T.A. Barron’s saga had been recommended to me for some time, and as such I can’t help but feel that it was overhyped for me. Although I enjoyed the book throughout, I certainly wasn’t caught by the desperate need to keep turning the pages or any sense of genuine fear that Merlin wouldn’t be able to complete his task. Though the series (so far) is fun and engaging, I certainly wouldn’t rank it anywhere near the likes of Lloyd Alexander‘s THE CHRONICLES OF PRYDAIN or Lucy Boston‘s THE CHILDREN OF GREEN KNOWE books, both of which also combine coming-of-age stories with a fantasy setting.

Merlin himself is a nice enough protagonist, though some of his development doesn’t feel entirely organic. At the beginning of the book he’s seized with newfound hubris, causing him to act in such a way that kick-starts the plot, but one can feel the authorial fiat at work. His fatal flaw springs out of nowhere just so he can grow out of it over the course of the story, learning a nugget of wisdom at each landmark spread throughout Fincayra. Rhia makes for a suitable companion on Merlin’s journey, strong and vulnerable in turn, but the character of Bumbelwy – a jester who can’t tell a joke – is just annoying.

Likewise, some of the idiosyncrasies present in the speech patterns of certain characters get extremely irritating. The Grand Elusa draws out every word she speaks: “Iiiit iiis eeeven possiiible that, ooone daaay, youuu maaay beee wiiise enouuugh tooo caaarry ooone ooof theee Treasuuures aaand nooot destroooy mooore thaaan youuu creaaate.” It’s like that for a whole chapter, and she didn’t speak this way in the previous book (I went back and checked) so I’ve no idea why she’s doing it now. Then there’s Shim the giant, who turns all his adjectives into adverbs: “Is you certainly? Nobody goes there on purposely. You is foolishly! I misses you, and you too, sweetly Rhia. I hopes to makes another crossing with you one daily.” Fincayra: the magical island where everyone has a speech impediment.

I sat up straighter when the book introduces the character of Vivien (nicknamed Nimue), who is of course a familiar figure from Arthurian mythology and a crucial player in Merlin’s future, but her evilness is projected too soon and so obviously that any suspense or ambiguity that might have been raised over her nature/motivation is over before it’s even begun. Excalibur also makes its debut in this instalment, but is introduced with so little fanfare that it’s easy to miss.

I don’t mean to be negative, honestly I don’t. Barron writes well and the stories open up an intriguing window as to what Merlin’s childhood could have been like. No doubt more aspects of the Arthurian mythos will be added as the series goes on, as well as the fruition of seeds that Barron has planted throughout the story pertaining to his own vision of what Merlin will become. But to me at least, the “x factor” is missing. It’s hard to describe what it is exactly (that’s why we call it the “x factor”) I only know that I’m not as invested as I should be. I have the next book The Raging Fires on hand – I’ll give that a try and see if I want to continue further.

Worth noting is that this series has recently been reprinted, and this instalment’s old title is The Seven Songs of Merlin. Rest assured that the text is unaltered, so make sure you don’t double-up on copies.

Merlin — (1996-2010) Ages 9-12. Publisher: Spat out by the sea, the boy lay on the rocks, as still as death. Even if he survived the day, he had no home. No memory. And no name. So begins the tale of the strange young boy, who having washed up on the shores of ancient Wales, is determined to find his real home and his true name. One day he will become the greatest wizard of all time, but he knows nothing of this now. At the knee of the mysterious Branwen, who claims to be his mother, the boy learns lore of the Celts, Druids, and people even more ancient. Yet the secret of his identity seems always to escape him. To discover the truth, and the secret of his own powers, he runs away, voyaging to the mist-shrouded side of Fincayra, an enchanted land between earth and sky that is being destroyed by blight. It is there he discovers that the fate of this land and his quest are strangely entwined? Combining all the passion, power, and spiritual depth that are T. A. Barron’s hallmarks, this book adds a thrilling new dimension to the legend of Merlin.

book review t.a. barron the lost years of merlin book review t.a. barron the lost years of merlin the seven songs of merlinbook review t.a. barron the lost years of merlin the fires of merlinbook review t.a. barron the lost years of merlin the mirror of merlinbook review t.a. barron the lost years of merlin the wings of merlinT.A. Barron Merlin's Dragon 2. Doomraga's RevengeT.A. Barron Merlin's Dragon 2. Doomraga's Revenge 3. Ultimate MagicT.A. Barron Merlin's Dragon 2. Doomraga's Revenge 3. Ultimate Magicbook review t.a. barron the great tree of avalon 1 child of the dark prophecybook review t.a. barron the great tree of avalon 2 shadows on the starsbook review t.a. barron the great tree of avalon 3 the eternal flame


SHARE:  Facebooktwitterredditpinteresttumblrmail  FOLLOW:  Facebooktwitterrsstumblr
If you plan to buy this book, you can support FanLit by clicking on the book cover above and buying it (and anything else) at Amazon. It costs you nothing extra, but Amazon pays us a small referral fee. Click any book cover or this link. We use this income to keep the site running. It pays for website hosting, postage for giveaways, and bookmarks and t-shirts. Thank you!

REBECCA FISHER, with us since January 2008, earned a Masters degree in literature at the University of Canterbury in New Zealand. Her thesis included a comparison of how C.S. Lewis and Philip Pullman each use the idea of mankind’s Fall from Grace to structure the worldviews presented in their fantasy series. Rebecca is a firm believer that fantasy books written for children can be just as meaningful, well-written and enjoyable as those for adults, and in some cases, even more so. Rebecca lives in New Zealand. She is the winner of the 2015 Sir Julius Vogel Award for Best SFF Fan Writer.

View all posts by

Review this book and/or Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *