The Revolutions: A hodgepodge that works

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsThe Revolutions by Felix Gilman fantasy book reviewsThe Revolutions by Felix Gilman

At not quite the halfway point in Felix Gilman’s The Revolutions, the main character — Arthur Shaw — reacts to a particular text he is reading:

It was a hodge-podge of Masonry, Greek myth, Egyptian fantasy, debased Christianity, third-hand Hinduism, and modern and ancient astronomy, promiscuously and nonsensically mixed . . . The Book was riddled throughout with paradox and absurdity and contradiction . . . But after a week or two of study, Arthur began to enjoy it.

And it is at this point where a reader might stop and think, “Yes, yes I am,” even as he/she mentally expands that list of hodge-podge foundations: “And C.S. Lewis and Burroughs and Yeats and Poe and Stevenson and The Sun and maybe a bit of Susanna Clarke and and and . . ., “ before remembering that the book in question was not in fact The Revolutions itself, but a text within that text. And so after that brief moment of dislocation, the reader might continue on, thinking they had for an instant caught a glimpse of something behind what they’d been looking at, had, for a moment, been transported wholly elsewhere — an entirely appropriate feeling with this novel. A novel I thoroughly enjoyed, though I confess I’m seldom bothered by hodgepodges and absurdities. Those who are might admittedly find themselves less enamored.

The Revolutions is set in a late-1800s London filled with fog and both fanciers and practitioners of the occult, many of whom are clear frauds, but a surprising number of whom, it turns out, have some actual talent, ranging across an entire spectrum of social/economic classes and of abilities — from lords and ladies to clerks and sailors, from the meanest of fortune-tellers to the most puissant of magicians and witches. It begins with a great storm that leads to an off-chance meeting between Arthur and the other main character, Josephine Bradman. Soon, the two are in a whirlwind of courtship, engagement, and debts, as Arthur has recently lost his job as a science writer for a small journal. Josephine’s job as a typist/translator for spiritualists will not pay the bills, but it does lead to their meeting with Lord Atwood, who invites Josephine, a strong “sensitive” in his judgment, to join his much more serious occult group (the focus of which is out-of-body travel) and also throws a bone of a job to Arthur.

They both accept, and both roles soon spiral out of control into disaster — Arthur is nearly driven mad by “the work” as it is called, while Josephine finds her spirit self severed from her body, the former trapped on a moon of Mars while the latter lies in a coma in London. As Josephine tries to communicate with the moon’s people and find her way back from that direction, Arthur throws himself even deeper into the machinations of Atwood’s group, seeing that as his only hope of finding his fiancée again, though to do so he’ll have to help Atwood stand against other English magicians ranged against his occult cabal.

Astral travel, lost Mars civilizations, mind powers, strange winged creatures, ancient evil, magical warfare, insanity and near-insanity, visions, witches, strange computations, bodily transformations, difference engines, secret societies, Eastern mystics, potions, conjurations, romance, chase scenes, fire and flood, prophetic dreams, shootings and stabbings, red sand and ruins, murder and kidnapping, betrayals and dark secrets. It’s all here. A hodgepodge, so to say.

And mostly I loved it. The plot flew by the majority of the time. The opening might be a little slow as characters are introduced and relationships set into place, and it doesn’t help much that the two main characters don’t actually feel much like a couple, but each are interesting enough in their own vein to carry us through to the point, at about page 75 or so, where they meet Atwood and the pace really picks up. From there, the pacing is impeccable, never lagging but also never going at an annoyingly breakneck speed.

The plot unfolds nicely in terms of mysteries behind mysteries, and once Josephine is stranded away from Earth, the dual storyline works quite well to both create suspense and also to offer up an entire other setting that is more fantastical and more complicated than the Earth-bound one, and that also allows for a more lyrically descriptive style, which Gilman handles with aplomb.

If I have any complaint with the plot, it is that Gilman throws so much into the mix that some of it gets lost either for long periods of time or simply dropped. Arthur’s writing, for instance, which is where we begin, with him composing a new fictional detective to take the place of the just-killed-off Sherlock Holmes, is quickly dropped, only to get a passing reference at the extreme end. The perhaps-mysterious death of an important figure, which is made much of in terms of focus early on, is forgotten for a time, until it is solved in almost throwaway fashion, never to be raised again.

Some of this happens with the characters as well, particularly side ones. If their relationship isn’t particularly moving, each of the two main characters is interesting enough to carry their individual storylines. Josephine is the best drawn and most compelling, both by nature of her personality and her dramatic situation. Arthur himself makes a somewhat too abrupt change in character I’d say, in terms of determination and ability, and is of more narrative interest due to plot than character. The other characters mostly have a sense of unmet potential, many of them intriguing in theory thanks to little hints of their nature or motivations, but less interesting in execution. Among these are Atwood, who actually devolves a bit as a character; Lord Podmore, a powerful magician opposed to Atwood’s group and one who I would have liked to have seen used to better effect; Archer, an intriguingly mysterious witch; Orpheus, an off-worlder; Sun, a member of Atwood’s group; and Vaz, one of Arthur’s co-workers. All of them felt like they were just on the edge of tipping over into fully realized characters entirely interesting in their own right, but they never quite did make that move.

Normally, this would have been more of a hindrance to my enjoyment of the novel, but I took so much pleasure in the nature of the plot, the old-time feel and echoes, and in the vividness of the prose, that the problems with characterization were noticeable but relatively minor. And if Gilman dropped the ball a bit with individual characters, I thought he was wonderfully on in his evocation of larger groups, whether it be the small in number spiritualist groups; the much wider view of English society at the turn of the society, when the past world of superstition blended almost seamlessly into the new world of science and when small harbingers of grand changes were barely making themselves known; or in the portrayal of a once-grand Mars civilization long collapsed, the lessons of which should perhaps be heeded by that younger civilization just beginning to stretch outward.

Sure, riddled with some flaws. And yes, definitely a hodgepodge. But unlike Arthur’s reading of his occult text, it didn’t take me “a week or two” to enjoy The Revolutions. It took me about five minutes to begin enjoying it and that feeling stayed with me for the ensuing five or six hours in a single sitting it took to finish it. Sometimes a hodgepodge is just a mess, its disparate parts canceling each other out and leading to a dull confusion. But sometimes, it’s like that great meal you make when you just throw everything that’s about to go bad in your fridge into the pot and let it simmer. Grab a bowl while Gilman’s ladling it out.

~Bill Capossere


The Revolutions by Felix Gilman fantasy book reviewsFelix Gilman is an excellent stylist and amazing fantasist, and someone hardly anyone seems to be reading. This baffles me. Tor has given his latest book The Revolutions a nice treatment with a clever, themed cover and everything. Gilman once again shows off his imagination and his style in this odd and captivating book.

The book is kind of like a marbled cake; two somewhat different stories swirled together… or maybe three. In an 1894 England very much like ours, a devastating storm opens the book, does incredible damage, destroys a strange device called The Engine, and leads to the meeting of Arthur Shaw and Josephine Bradman, the two main characters. Arthur and Josephine take to each other and strike up a courtship, even though the magazine where Arthur wrote has gone out of business, and his debts are mounting. Josephine is well educated and has some success as a poet but now she mostly transcribes documents for people. Arthur and Josephine are on the fringes of the spiritual movement and come to the attention of a circle of magicians. Soon, Arthur is offered a job at the rebuilt Engine, and Josephine has progressed from recording minutes at spiritualist meetings to participating as “one of the nine” in the magical group, run by Lord Atwood.

The tone of the early pages of the book is slightly remote, formal, convincingly evoking a sense of the period, but beneath the surface there are secrets and mysteries. The work Arthur does at the Engine makes no sense and drives some of the workers mad. The storm was no natural event, but a weapon called up by a rival of Lord Atwood, and the magical skirmishes continue. Lord Podmore, the rival, is more powerful socially that Atwood, and there are dark hints of American and Chinese magicians who are even more dire. Atwood himself is no prize though, and Josephine privately wonders who is the greater danger, Atwood’s enemies or his friends. When another accident takes place at the Engine, and Arthur barely escapes with his life, he rushes to Atwood’s house to rescue Josephine, who is participating in a ritual. Arthur’s ill-timed interruption has catastrophic consequences.

Josephine has the longest journey and the best adventure, to my mind, in the book, but Arthur is a close second. Arthur, who is riddled with self-doubt, has to assume the courage and confidence to act. Along the way he makes several errors in judgment, powering the plot and making him a convincingly human protagonist. Josephine, at one point, thinks that everyone says she is strong, but questions the value of her strength since she is still lost.

The story soon leaves London and Earth behind, moving to a different realm entirely. It may be another planet. Here Gilman’s powers of description come into play as he gives us not only ancient ruins and deserted cities, but a race of people who are not human and who do not communicate the way humans do. Gilman manages to create a world that seems like something a Victorian writer would have imagined for the face of Mars.

Arthur comes to this place with a group of other men, including Lord Atwood. Some of the expedition members are not as well developed as the earlier characters have been. Still, the sense of strangeness and foreboding carried me along.

It’s hard not to love a book that has a magical food-fight in an upper-crust, sophisticated London restaurant. It isn’t played for laughs; while the scene is humorous in many ways, it is also suspenseful and serious, a true magical battle. Gilman is one of the few writers I know who could pull that off.

My favorite book by Gilman is still The Half-Made World, but The Revolutions carried me away. I felt as if I were reading a newly discovered manuscript by H. Rider Haggard, or a true secret history of the Great Magical War of 1894. Why isn’t everyone reading this guy? I don’t get it.

~Marion Deeds

The Revolutions — (2014) Publisher: Following his spectacularly reviewed The Half-Made World duology, Felix Gilman pens a sweeping stand-alone tale of Victorian science fiction, space exploration, and planetary romance in The Revolutions. In 1893, as young journalist Asa Shaw is at work in British Museum Reading Room, a storm hits London and wreaks unprecedented damage. In its aftermath, Asa’s newspaper closes, owing him money, and all his debts come due at once. His fiance Jo takes a job as a stenographer for some of the fashionable spiritualist and occult societies of fin de siècle London society. Asa accompanies her to one of these meetings and is given a job lead. It seems to be accounting work, but at a salary many times what any clerk could expect. The work is long and peculiar, and the men spend all day performing unnerving calculations that make them hallucinate or even go mad…but the money is compelling. Things are beginning to look up when the wages of dabbling in the esoteric suddenly come due: A war breaks out between competing magical societies, and Asa interrupts Jo in the middle of an elaborate occult exploration. This rash move turns out to be dire, as Jo’s consciousness is stranded at the outer limits of a psychic day trip. Which, Asa is chagrined to find, was somewhere in the vicinity of Mars. Asa won’t give up the love of his life so easily and vows to do anything it takes to reunite her mind and body…even if he must follow her to Mars.

SHARE:  facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail  FOLLOW:  facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinrsstumblr
If you plan to buy this book, you can support FanLit by clicking on the book cover above and buying it (and anything else) at Amazon. It costs you nothing extra, but Amazon pays us a small referral fee. Click any book cover or this link. We use this income to keep the site running. It pays for website hosting, postage for giveaways, and bookmarks and t-shirts. Thank you!

BILL CAPOSSERE, who's been with us since June 2007, lives in Rochester NY, where he is lately spending much of his time trying to finish a book-length collection of essays and a full-length play. His prior work has appeared in Colorado Review, Rosebud, Alaska Quarterly, and other journals and been recognized in the "Notable Essays" section of several Best American Essay anthologies. When he's not writing, reading, reviewing, co-writing the Malazan Empire re-read at Tor.com, or working as an English adjunct, he can usually be found with his wife and son on the frisbee golf course, the ultimate frisbee field, or trying to keep up with his wife's flute and his son's trumpet on the clarinet he just picked up this month.

View all posts by

MARION DEEDS, with us since March 2011, is retired from a 35-year career with county government, where she met enough interesting characters and heard enough zany stories to inspire at least two trilogies’ worth of fantasy fiction. Currently she spends part of her time working at a local used bookstore. She is an aspiring writer herself and, in the 1990s, had short fiction published in small magazines like Night Terrors, Aberrations, and in the cross-genre anthology The Magic Within. On her blog Deeds & Words, she reviews many types of books and follows developments in food policy and other topics.

View all posts by

5 comments

  1. Gilman has a new one? How did I miss this?!

  2. Paul (@princejvstin) /

    I dunno…I certainly read Gilman :)

  3. I tried two different books and in one I didn’t like the characters enough to care what was happening and the other one bored me to tears.

  4. I hope the nobody-reading-Gilman is a matter of perception and not reality because that would be a shame. I agree his Half-Made World is his best, but the others aren’t far behind and his originality is certainly refreshing. Nice review!

  5. Some people are put off by the degree of distance between the reader and the characters, I think.

    I assume people aren’t reading him because I never read/hear much about him on blogs, etc; so maybe that is merely a perception.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *