1286 Fantasy Authors New SFF Releases FanLit Reviewers FanLit Features HOME

The Hidden Stars: Overwritten and uneven


July 1st, 2007  Posted by Rob Rhodes (retired)

Madeline Howard The Rune of Unmaking 1. The Hidden Stars 2. A Dark Sacrifice fantasy book reviewsbook review Madeline Howard The Rune of Unmaking The Hidden StarsThe Hidden Stars by Madeline Howard

A small band of wizards and warriors must find the lost royal child prophesied to end the reign of an ‘evil’, self-proclaimed goddess-empress. Adapting that main plotline from Willow, Madeline Howard’s novel The Hidden Stars further combines several Tolkien-esque elements (wondrously dexterous elves/fey; vastly powerful wizards; not nine but twelve misshapen servants of the villain) to create an initially promising but unfortunately disappointing fantasy experience. Many fantasy plots have been explored time and again. What matters is the execution, and that’s where this story falls short… Read the rest.

  • email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS
´s rating: | | | Fantasy Book ReviewsCOMMENT (0)

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or



      Copyright © 2007-2012 Fantasy Literature's Fantasy Book and Audiobook Reviews. All rights reserved.




  • RSS
  • Newsletter
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Google+
  • Digg
  • Delicious
  • Slider


Join us at Google+
We have 2970 fantasy book reviews.
Random FanLit Review:
    Tris's Book: A wonderful character: Tris's Book by Tamora Pierce This volume is the second in a four-part series called Circle of Magic and is also titled The Power in the Storm. Set in a fantasy realm over a one-year period, Tamora Pierce tells the story of four young mages who are brought toget...


RECENT DISCUSSION:
Jesse Hudson: Bill, great review. Nicely laid out with opinion and evidence, and thus trustworthy. :) A curiosity question for you: do you think it wise that f...
Bryce: @Kat - The first one is amazing, especially the first 1/3 or so. I still need to get to the next one....
Mary Anderson: Awesome news from Janny Wurts. Been a fan for many years and always psyched to see the next volume in the works!...
Kat Hooper: Tizz, I even looked it up in the print book just to make sure that was the word, even though it was obvious from the context....
Kat Hooper: I really like Matthew Hughes -- I've got to read that To Hell and Back series....
Marion Deeds: TWO RAVENS AND ONE CROW -- I think they were in the redwwod tree behind my house during the eclipse. Delightful, enticing title!...
Maria (BearMountainBooks): Greatly looking forward to the Jim Hines novel!!...
John Hulet on Facebook: LOL... Can I like my own review?...
Tizz: Like Marion, I read this back in the 70s and had a similar reaction to yours even then. Not surprised to hear it hasn't aged well. As to "diMEZZni" -...
Nora-Adrienne Deret: I actually have most of the series on my bookshelf still. I enjoyed reading them and so did my eldest son....
Bill Capossere: Just remembered. He and his mates do get pretty drunk in one scene, though they do pay for it the day . .....
Marion Deeds: Hmm. I picked up this book back in the 1970s and tried to read it; didn't get very far. I'm please to see that I didn't miss something vital! Thanks, ...
Kat Hooper: Thanks, Bill! I'll pick this up for Jesse....
Bill Capossere: word-wise, difficult for a 13-yr-old though probably no different than if you gave a kid an unadapted/unabridged version of Kidnapped or Treasure Isla...
Marion Deeds: I can't WAIT! (Well, actually I kind of have to, because my coy hasn't arrived yet. But you know what I mean.)...
Kat Hooper: Yeah, the covers are really nice. Maybe later books get more original....
Kat Hooper: Bill, suitable for my 13 year old son?...
Mandy: Easing the Badger from the Dragon Reborn - what an amazingly euphemistic name!...
Marion: THE BLACK SUN'S DAUGHTER sounds intriguing,and I love Kat Richardson's stuff. I think I'm pretty much done with October Daye....
Jon Baxley on Facebook: Thanks for the friend invitation. If you or any of your friends are historical fantasy fans, check out my medieval Scottish epic, THE BLACKGLOOM BOUNT...
Terry Weyna: Seanan McGuire writes the Toby Daye books, yeah. I think you might want to try the second book in the series to see if you like it a bit better than ...
Kelly Lasiter: Yup! She even jokes on her blog about her different pen names having different fashion sense....
Marion: Okay, because I'm too lazy to look it up, @Terry, please help me. Seanan McGuire writes the October Daye series, yes? I didn't care much for the first...
Marion: The covers are neat. I think there are writers who can't decipher what makes a book magic (for me, it is often about the relationships between authent...
Maria (BearMountainBooks): It has a great cover tho!...





Admin