The Gathering Storm: WOT is in good hands

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsfantasy book reviews Robert Jordan Brandon Sanderson The Wheel of Time: The Gathering StormThe Gathering Storm by Robert Jordan & Brandon Sanderson

That the twelfth book in a series is entitled The “Gathering” Storm probably points to a fundamental problem with the series. I mean, we’re eleven books (long, long books by the way) down and the storm is only just “gathering”? And anyone who has stuck with The Wheel of Time thus far (which I’m assuming is pretty much everyone reading this because otherwise why the heck are you reading this?), knows that pacing has been a big problem in Robert Jordan’s work, especially after the first few books. I wonder, in fact, if part of the reason for the title was a special publisher’s plea to wavering fans: “the end is coming! No, really! It’s almost here!” Though in that case, perhaps announcing that the final book was going to be split into three wasn’t such a smart idea…

Well, I can say that, whether intentional or not, The Gathering Storm does mostly deliver on its seeming promise of a quickening end. Brandon Sanderson, in place of Robert Jordan, has offered up a book that moves more quickly than its 800 pages would seem to indicate. It doesn’t match the compelling joyful pace of the first few WOT books, but it does mostly zip along, resolving plot events from earlier books, opening up new paths, clearing away some of the narrative and character underbrush. I’d say it’s a somewhat stronger version of Knife of Dreams in that regard (though I consider KoD a pale version of the first 3 or 4 novels). While The Gathering Storm does still have some side-plots that dilute the potential impact of major storylines, new narrative lines seem a bit more focused on getting us where we need to get to. And some of the more repetitive aspects of previous plots have been dropped, though a big one — Rand’s hardening of himself — has been wearing a bit thin and continues to do so in The Gathering Storm. Not that it isn’t a good arc; it’s just been too stretched out.

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsThat said, while lots of separate things happen in The Gathering Storm, and while I’d say most of them need to happen in order for us to reach the end, it feels like the narrative moves along more speedily on the micro rather than the macro level. What I mean is that you feel the whoosh of singular events, but I can’t say by the end you feel any closer to the final confrontation, despite the crossed Ts and dotted I’s of prophecy and the unshackling of certain characters.

Beyond pacing, the plot is mostly serviceable, another similarity to Knife of Dreams. I can’t say there are any particularly stirring scenes, nor any particularly emotional ones save one nicely quiet one. There are a few pleasant surprises (which I won’t mention, of course) that feel well set-up and fully necessary to the plot as opposed to a twist for a twist’s sake. We don’t spend much time with Perrin, for which I’m quite thankful, as I’ve found his subplots to be by far the weakest. Matt’s storyline is semi-interesting but feels quite detached, more as if he’s simply being kept busy to remind us he’s around rather than being an integral part of the story. Egwene’s story was for me the least plausible, though I won’t go into specifics to avoid spoilers. I’ll just say I had a hard time accepting the premise of her situation, the length of it, and its resolution. Actually, the single most implausible scene involved a Forsaken: painfully, laughably implausible, and an example of one of the infuriating ways these books can be so inconsistent and so bad at points (a later scene involving that same Forsaken was better, though it could have been mined a bit more for impact). The ending — no spoilers, don’t worry — is a big jump forward in many ways and makes sense in terms of plot and character, but I found it far too abrupt and a bit too easy. I’m assuming and hoping that it turns out to be not as easy as it appeared.

There is mostly slight movement in characters (and one welcome change); some are humbled, some strengthened, some finally choose a side or change sides, most of them grow a little wiser, which is good to see. Development is slight, and self-awareness only burgeoning, in some, but believably so. And there is a lot less inconsistency in characterization — much less leaping from adamantine to simpering in a single bound.

Power has always been a major thematic element in the series and that continues in The Gathering Storm. What is power, where does it lie, who should wield it, what is the impact on those who do so, what lines (if any) are drawn, when do the ends justify the means, what are the responsibilities of those who wield it or give it up, etc. are explored through character and sometimes through interior monologue. This has always been, I think, one of Jordan’s strongest and most subtle (usually) aspects and it remains a strength here as characters and readers alike wrestle with these and similar questions.

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsThe prose, like the plot, is adequate. There aren’t any truly memorable or beautiful lines, but overall I’d say Brandon Sanderson’s prose is an improvement on Robert Jordan’s. Unfortunately, we still experience some of those same tics which I’m guessing are from Jordan’s own passages. Thus we get the “hands folded beneath her breasts,” some braid-pulling, “flimsy” and “diaphanous” gowns, various busts and bosoms, and bottoms being spanked. It feels like there’s less of all this, but it still stands out. In general Sanderson has kept the flavor of Jordan’s prose, for all its good and bad points, but has streamlined, and thus improved, it.

Overall, The Gathering Storm is better than many books in the series, though nowhere near as good as the best ones. It lacks the major flaws of earlier books and has reduced the minor niggling ones to only a few occasions. And it leaves us ready, it appears, to move (let’s hope) more quickly toward the end. There’s no reason for a recommendation as — let’s face it — if you’re reading this review you’re going to be reading The Gathering Storm (if not, you really need to find a better way of entertaining yourself), but I do think The Gathering Storm will leave most readers feeling that WOT is in good hands and is pulling itself out of that hole it dug for itself.

~Bill Capossere

fantasy book reviews Robert Jordan Brandon Sanderson The Wheel of Time: The Gathering StormSince Bill has extensively reviewed The Gathering Storm I’ll just add a few of my impressions and address the audio version.

First of all, I’m happy to report that THE WHEEL OF TIME is slowly getting somewhere. Though The Gathering Storm is excessively and needlessly lengthy (why do I, after all this time, still need the clothing styles of each country detailed?), a few things actually happen. And a few important things! Some storylines are mercifully wrapped up and it finally appears that the “storm” is truly “gathering” and that perhaps we might actually see some rain or lightning in the next volume.

Also importantly, the transition from Robert Jordan to Brandon Sanderson has been seamless. I have no idea how much of The Gathering Storm was written by Mr. Jordan before his death, but it all felt like Mr. Jordan. A couple of times I thought I detected Brandon Sanderson in the background during the Mat chapters, but this is a good thing because I like Sanderson’s sense of humor. Good job, Mr. Sanderson!

The seamless transition is mainly a good thing, but it means that most of the issues I’ve had with THE WHEEL OF TIME are still there — the pace is excruciatingly slow (for all the pages in this big book and all the traveling going on, there’s not much overall plot movement), there are too many characters with similar names (I had to look up several of them at Encyclopedia WOT), and each of the cultures is unrealistically stereotyped (e.g., the Aiel still won’t look at horses, the Domani women are seductive, etc). There are fewer braid pulls this time, though spanking is still the preferred method of punishment.

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsAs Bill said (above), The Gathering Storm is very much like Knife of Dreams. The plot is moving toward resolution, but there’s a lot of filler along the way. Bill reported that Sanderson had streamlined the prose, but honestly I couldn’t detect that; it sounded the same to me. However, this may be because I was listening to The Gathering Storm on audio with the familiar voices of husband-and-wife team Michael Kramer and Kate Reading.

And speaking of the audio, here’s a confession: Listening to a WHEEL OF TIME novel on audio is a massive undertaking: 33 hours of life in this case. Not only is the pace of the novel too slow, but Kramer and Reading read it too slowly, also. But I have a trick for this: I speed up the audio to 1.4 times normal speed and then it’s tolerable. In fact, it sounds like a normal reading rate at this speed. I recommend the audio version if you have the capability of speeding it up. If you don’t, make sure you’re up to 33 hours of leisurely listening or else get the print version.

~Kat Hooper

SHARE:  Facebooktwitterredditpinteresttumblrmail  FOLLOW:  Facebooktwitterrsstumblr
If you plan to buy this book, you can support FanLit by clicking on the book cover above and buying it (and anything else) at Amazon. It costs you nothing extra, but Amazon pays us a small referral fee. Click any book cover or this link. We use this income to keep the site running. It pays for website hosting, postage for giveaways, and bookmarks and t-shirts. Thank you!

BILL CAPOSSERE, who's been with us since June 2007, lives in Rochester NY, where he is an English adjunct by day and a writer by night. His essays and stories have appeared in Colorado Review, Rosebud, Alaska Quarterly, and other literary journals, along with a few anthologies, and been recognized in the "Notable Essays" section of Best American Essays. His children's work has appeared in several magazines, while his plays have been given stage readings at GEVA Theatre and Bristol Valley Playhouse. When he's not writing, reading, reviewing, or teaching, he can usually be found with his wife and son on the frisbee golf course or the ultimate frisbee field.

View all posts by

KAT HOOPER, who started this site in June 2007, earned a Ph.D. in neuroscience and psychology at Indiana University (Bloomington) and now teaches and conducts brain research at the University of North Florida. When she reads fiction, she wants to encounter new ideas and lots of imagination. She wants to view the world in a different way. She wants to have her mind blown. She loves beautiful language and has no patience for dull prose, vapid romance, or cheesy dialogue. She prefers complex characterization, intriguing plots, and plenty of action. Favorite authors are Jack Vance, Robin Hobb, Kage Baker, William Gibson, Gene Wolfe, Richard Matheson, and C.S. Lewis.

View all posts by


  1. I can’t wait to read this. I’m on my second read through this series. Love is not even the word. I’m glad to hear the good reviews.

  2. I listen to these on audio, so I’ll be downloading today.

  3. Very excited. It sounds like we have very similar takes on this series. I often call it the most annoying series I’ve ever become addicted to. I’m looking forward to reading it. Thx for the review.

  4. I still haven’t decided whether to try to get back into this series. The last one I read was Winter’s Heart, and then when I heard Crossroads of Twilight didn’t really advance the plot, I gave up. I’m tempted to give it another shot, since I liked the one Sanderson book I’ve read, but there’s the daunting prospect of rereading everything, since it’s been nearly ten years and I doubt I remember enough to just jump back in.

  5. “I often call it the most annoying series I’ve ever become addicted to”

    great description–sums it up perfectly!

  6. I’m half-way through, and so far, I am impressed. Sanderson has tightened up the story quite nicely, but my reaction to his treatment of Mat Cauthon is the same (there has been only one chapter so far on Mat): where is the real Mat and who is this person who looks like him?

    I actually find the Egwene chapters the most interesting, and her character is one that has grown considerably. I don’t find the pending resolution of the schism in the White Tower so manufactured as did Bill, but the seeds for that resolution should have been better sown in previous books.

    I’ll let you know what I think when I finish.

  7. So it doesn’t sound like Alvin and the Chipmunks when you speed it up? ;)

  8. haha, no! It just sounds like someone talking faster. In this case, it’s the speed I want to hear it anyway. It’s not like you really need to listen to it slowly — there’s nothing difficult to process. For some books I actually have to pause the audio and think, but not for a WOT book. :sleep:

  9. Too bad there’s no software that can pick out “tugged her braid” and make the CD skip those bits.

    In the audio book I’m listening to, I actually went to B&N and sneaked a look at the print version to make sure I’d heard something right. It was sort of a huge thing dropped in really casually and in an accent.

  10. When I have something I need to see in print, I use the “look inside” feature on Amazon which is searchable (if that book has it). Often, though, I borrow the print version from the library and use it for reference. If you’re listening to a new book, though (which I think you are), then you may not be able to get it at the library. And of course if the book isn’t out yet because you have an ARC, then you may not find it searchable, either.

  11. Is she still tugging her braid? I stopped reading part way through book one years ago because of that particular annoying habit.

  12. Sarah, it is obvious that Mr. Sanderson realizes we’re annoyed with the braid tugging. In this last book, a couple of times she grabs the braid and stops herself from tugging, or rationalizes why she can let herself succumb to the annoying habit. It’s clear he’s turned it into a habit she’s trying to kick, especially since she realizes that it’s an obvious sign that she’s annoyed or stressed or mad and she wants to hide these emotions like an Aes Sedai should.


  1. uberVU - social comments - Social comments and analytics for this post... This post was mentioned on Twitter by FanLit: The Gathering Storm: WOT…

Review this book and/or Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *