previous fantasy author
 

Meredith Ann Pierce

1958-
Reviewed by Rebecca Fisher
next fantasy author
Meredith Ann Pierce
The Darkangel was nominated for a Mythopoeic Award for adult fantasy literature. Learn more at Meredith Ann Pierce's website.





Click covers to view available formats, including audio & Kindle.

Darkangel — (1982-1989) Young adult. Publisher: The Darkangel, a vampire of astounding beauty and youth, can only summon his full power when he finds his 14th and final bride. But for Aeriel, whom he kidnaps to serve his brides, there is something about him — something beyond his obvious evil — that makes her want to save him rather than destroy him. The Darkangel — Pierce's first book, originally released in 1982 — was an ALA Best Book for Young Adults, a New York Times Notable Children's Book, a Parent's Choice Award Superbook, and a Booklist Best Book of the Decade.

Meredith Ann Pierce 1. The Darkangel 2. A Gathering of Gargoyles 3. The Pearl of the Soul of the World book review Meredith Ann Pierce 1. The Darkangel 2. A Gathering of Gargoyles 3. The Pearl of the Soul of the World book review Meredith Ann Pierce 1. The Darkangel 2. A Gathering of Gargoyles 3. The Pearl of the Soul of the World

book review Meredith Ann Pierce DarkangelThe Darkangel: An Incredible Tale

Meredith Ann Pierce 1. The Darkangel 2. A Gathering of Gargoyles 3. The Pearl of the Soul of the World I picked up The Darkangel the first time at my school library when I was 13 and I stayed up past three in the morning trying to finish it; It was that captivating. It has all the components of a fairytale, and yet is worked into a fantasy novel that includes vampires, gargoyles and other strange and macabre creatures.

Don't be put off by the word 'vampire' though; this book isn't yet another vampire book of that most over-used genre, but an incredible story with a huge scope and scale that stretches from a small village, to the vampire's forbidden castle, to a seemingly endless desert.

It begins when a young Aerial's mistress is kidnapped upon the hills by a dark angel, or a vampire. Taking it upon herself to rescue her, she sets off on a wonderful journey that includes characters you've only ever seen in myths and legends. With her bravery, kindness and story-telling abilities, Aerial gradually begins to lighten the darkangel's world and teach him of his own dark heritage.
Rebecca Fisher


book review Meredith Ann Pierce A Gathering of GargoylesA Gathering of Gargoyles: A Beautifully Crafted Tale, A Lost Masterpiece

book review Meredith Ann Pierce 1. The Darkangel 2. A Gathering of Gargoyles 3. The Pearl of the Soul of the World A Gathering of Gargoyles
is the second of Meredith Ann Pierce's Darkangel trilogy, beginning with The Dark Angel and culminating in The Pearl of the Soul of the World, which together create one of the most beautifully crafted and presented stories that I have ever come across. As told in The Darkangel, the story is of Aerial, a simple slave in a wealthy household whose mistress Eoduin was captured by one of the dreaded winged vampyres, who drink the blood and steals the souls of women. Aerial followed her mistress, becoming a servant in the Irrylath's house, and to her horror, eventually being chosen to be his last bride. But with the help of the dwarf-like duarough Talb and a magical drought, she restored the darkangel to humanity by literally exchanging hearts with him, and returned him to his mother's house.

And now Aerial is appointed another task set to her by the deceased spirits of the brides: to seek out the missing lons, the powerful animal-like wardens of the land who have long been missing, most likely due to the designs of the White Witch, the maker of the darkangels, who still haunts Irrylath's dreams. Despairing of her husband's inability to love her, Aerial takes up the task and sets off on a journey to the temple of the sibyl in her own homeland to unravel the mystery of an ancient riddle that will help her find the missing lons. Armed with a dark staff with a heron passenger, she not only seeks the lons, but unknowingly finds the secrets of her own past, and her role in the destiny that follows in the war against the Witch.

Unlike The Darkangel, which was created in more of a circular narrative in the fairytale motifs of capture, trial and restoration (much like in Sleeping Beauty or Snow White), A Gathering of Gargoyles is a voyaging novel, with an ultimate goal hindered by several obstacles. And these obstacles, far from dragging the story on, are fascinating: a sail across a Sea-of-Dust, hidden danger in a City of Thieves, a chase through a dark forest filled with night-haunts, the rescue of a rather unusual maiden sacrifice, a time of being held in captivity by a man who has sold his own name, the relighting of a great lighthouse, and finally, with the meeting of two familiar characters from the first book — one good and one evil — the climax of the quest.

Although the premise may look silly written down, perhaps seeming to belong to a trashy vampiric-romance paperback, I assure you it is not. Meredith Pierce creates a world with depth and resonance, perfectly mingling together elements of many cultures — the German loreleis, the European gargoyles, the Grecian sphinx — into a familiar, yet totally unique blend. Unlike many fantasy authors — and Tolkien imitators these days, who feel as if they must cram detail upon detail into their books in order to make it seem realistic (but only succeeding in making them encyclopedic), Pierce creates exotic worlds and its wildlife with barely any effort; a different way of keeping time, a new range of foods and plants (including 'hungerspice', 'nightfruit', and 'winesheath') and vivid descriptions of scenery that do not inflict directly on the story or slow it down, but simply serve to convincingly create an entire world separate from this one. Likewise, she keeps in mind the separate sects of her land, as in different countries the terrain and communities change, as does the language — in one place a darkangel is called an 'icarus', and in another it is called a 'seraph'. All is told in an elegant and simple tone, as if Pierce is retelling a story, giving the book an air of being an ancient folklore retold.

Much of the charm of the books is the heroine, Aerial herself. In a politically correct world where authors feel as if female protagonists must be able to swing a sword in order to be considered 'strong female characters' equal to males, it is wonderful to discover a resourceful, intelligent, compassionate, strong-willed female who experiences hardship and triumphs over the odds without once resorting to violence (expect a couple of self-defensive maneuvers with a staff). Such heroines are increasingly getting harder to come by, but are always more realistic and interesting to female and male readers. I for one would have absolutely no clue what to do if someone handed me a sword, and Aerial, with her faults and virtues is a pleasure to read of.

The entire story reads like an old, dark fairytale, with traditional elements given new life — an invisibility cloak, magic fruit, a damsel to be sacrificed, a sacrificial stone — all sound like utter clichés, but are deliberately presented here in such originality that it is if you are reading of them for the first time. These books have my highest recommendation — everything about them appealed to me, from the content to the underlying themes to the style of the writing. Why these books remain largely unknown is a mystery to me, as Meredith Ann Pierce's talent as a storyteller is right up there with the masters of the fantasy genre. —Rebecca Fisher


book review Meredith Ann Pierce The Pearl of the Soul of the World DarkangelThe Pearl of the Soul of the World: "Ravenna's Own Daughter Shall Kindle the Crown..."

book review Meredith Ann Pierce 1. The Darkangel 2. A Gathering of Gargoyles 3. The Pearl of the Soul of the World As the last installment of the Darkangel trilogy, The Pearl of the Soul of the World had a lot to live up to, as well as a lot to wrap up. In the first book The Darkangel, slavegirl Aerial saved the darkangel Irrylath from the misery of his own existence under the power of the White Witch and returned him to his mother's house. In A Gathering of Gargoyles she undertook another task, in searching for the lost lons to fight against the White Witch in the coming battle and in doing so discovered her own extraordinary heritage. Now the various countries of Aerial's world have gathered together in a great army to march against the witch, with her husband Irrylath at its head.

But the story begins in the most unexpected way. As the story opens, we find a young woman in a cave deep underground, with no memory of who she is, mute, with a silver pin driven through her temple and a sinister feeling that someone is following her. Although the amnesia plot device may seem cliched to some, Pierce uses it brilliantly by instigating it right from the beginning, so that the girl's identity and the events that led up to her awakening in the cave are kept shrouded until the time is right (and as it turns out, her forgetfulness plays an important role in the narrative; it's not just a silly plot twist and it's not brought on by a bump on the head).

Found by three duaroughs (beardless dwarfs basically), the young girl accompanies them through tunnels and caverns, all the time endangered by the presence of the witch's evil creatures. Eventually the girl finds a hidden passage to the ancient city of Crystalglass where the last of the Ancients — Ravenna — awaits reveal to her the truth of the White Witch and the world's history and to give her a final task: deliver a (literal!) pearl of wisdom into the Witch's own hand.

The girl (as you've probably guessed) is indeed Aerial, and when she meets Ravenna her memories return to her. We learn what happened in the space between A Gathering of Gargoyles and the time she found herself in the underground caves, (including the gathering of Irrylath's army, the rebirth of Avarclon, the equine lon that died in the first book, and Aerial's newfound reputation as a powerful sorceress). Most importantly of all is the dynamics between herself, her devoted servant Erin, her detached husband Irrylath and his cousin Sabr. Pierce excellently and poignantly weaves the bonds that tie these people together; Aerial's hopeless love for Irrylath, his seeming indifference toward her, Erin's devotion to Aerial and her scorn for Irrylath, and Sabr's sneaky innuendoes to discredit Aerial and snatch Irrylath for herself. It's certainly a tangled web of intrigue!

As well as these core characters Pierce also keeps good track of the rest of her (by this stage, rather large) cast of characters, all of whom have an interesting and vital part to play in the progression of the story. As such, we have reappearances from Talb, Syllva, Eoduin and the maidens, the Ma'a-mbai, the lons, Irrylath's brothers and Roshka. Only Roshka was a tad underused — as Aerial's newly discovered brother I would have liked to have seen more of the bond between siblings. Pierce's gift is that none of her characters are strictly good or evil, and just as Aerial must cope with her jealously of Sabr and the pain she feels in regard to Irrylath; Sabr herself is not wholly bad, acting as she does out of love for Irrylath. And as for the White Witch... well, I don't want to give her story away, but let's just say she is given a name, a heritage and a heartbreaking motivation for the evils she does during the course of the story. Just as a darkangel was once redeemed, so too is there hope for the Witch... if she chooses to take it.

Pierce creates a vivid portrayal of a world; which is hinted at being our own terraformed moon set far into the future. Ideas that Pierce brings into the narrative, such as the reasons behind why the moon was terraformed in the first place and the ultimate fate of 'Oceanus', should resonate in the readers' minds as contemporary statements of our world's present condition.

And then of course there's the ending which disappointed some fans. However, in my opinion there was no other possible way for the story to finish. Pierce carefully laid out the elements of the story, and the conclusion makes sense given the facts that she had established. The ending thus takes on a tragic, inevitable and fateful air, reminiscent of all the best love stories. Though saddened, I could understand why things happened the way they did.

BUT!

For all those who were upset at the conclusion, hope remains. In an interview, Meredith Ann Pierce had this to say:

"Anybody who considers that a satisfying ending is nuts. Take heart! I intend to shift focus to Irrylath and show him as a very human character coming to grips with a life of duty, devoid of personal satisfaction or love. No longer overshadowed by Aerial, Irrylath must forgive himself for his crimes as a darkangel, regain his wings and discover the secret that will set both him and Aerial free. Aerial will learn the high personal cost of surrendering herself, however nobly, to Ravenna's planetary rescue plan."

"Here end for a time the adventures of Aerial. The adventures of Irrylath have only begun" — this was the line that Pierce wanted to end The Pearl of the Soul of the World with until her publishers vetoed the decision. Now that we have hope for Irrylath and Aerial, all we can do is wait impatiently. Until then, The Darkangel trilogy is a fantastic set of books. —Rebecca Fisher

 

Firebringer — (1985-1996) Young adult. Publisher: Jan, the prince of the unicorns, is high-spirited, reckless — and the despair of his mighty father, Korr. Reluctantly, Korr allows Jan to accompany the other initiate warriors on a pilgrimage. Soon Jan's curiosity leads him, along with his friend Dagg, and their mentor, the female warrior Tek, into the greatest dangers — deadly gryphons, sly pans, wyverns, pards, and renegade unicorns. Yet time after time they are rescued, leading Jan to wonder: Am I the heir to a special destiny?

Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer review 1. Birth of the Firebringer 2. Dark Moon 3. The Son of Summer Stars Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer review 1. Birth of the Firebringer 2. Dark Moon 3. The Son of Summer Stars Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer review 1. Birth of the Firebringer 2. Dark Moon 3. The Son of Summer Stars

book review Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer, Birth of the FirebringerBirth of the Firebringer: "I Can Walk in Other's Dreams..."

Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer review 1. Birth of the Firebringer 2. Dark Moon 3. The Son of Summer Stars Meredith Ann Pierce is best known for her wonderful Darkangel trilogy, which sadly is not as renowned as it deserves to be. Even lesser known is Pierce's Firebringer trilogy, based on stories she wrote and dreams she experienced as a young child, which chronicle the lives and adventures of a tribe of unicorns exiled from their home.

Legend tells of how the unicorns were driven out from their Hallow Hills by the serpentine wyverns, who by trickery, superior numbers and mastery of fire, forced the Princess Halla to remove her people from their ancestral home and find new feeding grounds in the Vale. But all is not well; the unicorns pine for their true homelands, especially the Mirror of the Moon, to which a dangerous pilgrimage is done every year so that the young unicorns may drink and glimpse their destinies in its waters. As well as this there are pans (basically fauns, though they are never named as such), and vicious gryphons who terrorize their life in the Vale, and dangerous renegade unicorns that gallop the plain lands.

One hope lies upon the unicorns that they may one day reclaim their homelands; a vague and contradictory prophecy regarding a Firebringer, who will win back the Hills for his people. It is into this rugged landscape that the young Prince Alijan lives, who accompanies his father and fellow unicorns on the dangerous rite-of-passage to the Mirror of the Moon with his friends Dagg and Tek.

Jan has a lot to learn; about himself, his relationship with his father, and the world. Guided by both the mystic Jah-Lila, and the unicorn-goddess Alma, Jan begins a journey of discovery (continuing into the next two books) that will change his entire tribe's existence. In this volume, dealings with gryphons, pans and renegade unicorns all lead to a final confrontation with the manipulative wyvern queen, who holds for Jan a terrible truth.

Without close reading, the structure of the novel can appear painfully predictable; the young prince is headstrong and reckless, with a devoted sidekick, a strict father, a fiery love interest and a set destiny laid before him — you've read all this before, right? Wrong. Pierce displays a masterful stroke when it comes to portraying the forces of good and evil, mostly in regard to the fact that there aren't any. Throughout his journeys Jan becomes steadily aware of prejudices and assumptions within his own tribe, that many of their sacred beliefs are but superstition, and that perceived 'enemies' are only acting accordingly to their own natures, their own points of view. Even the wyverns, who are the undisputed villains of the novel, are given a place within the natural order of things. An underlying theme of pacifism, understanding and democracy is something rarely to be found in fantasy novels, especially as Jan's role as 'hero' has less to do with fighting than with enlightenment.

As well as this other cultures are handled with exceptional variety; the pans with their darts and story-telling dances, the gryphons with their warrior females and stay-at-home males, and of course the unicorns themselves with their traditions, lore, and activities. Also worth mentioning is the use of narrator within the novel, an anonymous and mysterious presence that is revealed only at the conclusion of the story and guides the reader through the lessons and wonders that Pierce has to share.

Though it's possible that Pierce will never outdo her first novel The Darkangel, this Firebringer trilogy makes a great read, memorable, original, poetically written and unique to the fantasy genre.
Rebecca Fisher


book review Meredith Ann Pierce Dark Moon FirebringerDark Moon: "See What Your Wychery has Wrought?!"

Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer review 1. Birth of the Firebringer 2. Dark Moon 3. The Son of Summer Stars Ever notice how the second parts of trilogies are often the weakest? This is not always the case, but it often happens in both books and movies, and it definitely occurs here. Dark Moon is the second part of The Firebringer trilogy, which began with the fascinating Birth of the Firebringer and ending with the explosive The Son of Summer Stars. But smack dab in the middle is Dark Moon, and though it is far from being a bad book, it is unfavorably compared to the volumes either side of it.

In the preceding novel we are introduced to the young Prince Alijan, whose name means 'dark moon', and who is the subject of a prophecy that describes the one who will eventually win back the Hallow Hills for the unicorns. Taken over by the poisonous wyverns, the unicorns were driven into exile and long to return to their ancestral home — especially since they now contend with gryphons, pans and renegade unicorns. Identified as the prophesied 'Firebringer', the chosen one of the goddess Alma, Alijan is slowly making changes within his herd — introducing them to new customs and cultures, creating peace between enemies and laying to rest some of the snobbery and superstition that plagues his people (much to the disgust of his conservative father Korr).

But all that is put on hold when Jan and the rest of the youths in the tribe travel to the shore to engage in mating rituals. It is there he is finally united with his beloved Tek, though it is for only a short while. A vicious gryphon attack cuts him off from the rest of his fellows, and he is swept off to sea. Presumed dead by his grieving friends, the unicorns travel home where Tek's union with Jan is met only with disgust by Korr. Considering them judged by Alma, Korr instigates a new regime for the coming winter that endangers the life of the entire tribe. Finding herself in foal, Tek escapes to her mother, the mystic Jah-Lila who lives as a renegade upon the plain.

Meanwhile, Jan finds himself washed up on a foreign shore with no memory of who he is or how he got there. Falling in with "two-leggers," Jan is conveyed to their great city where he is enraptured by their mastery of fire. Yet there are sinister goings-on within the city, which Jan becomes aware of when he is introduced to the hornless horses of the "two-leggers," who exist completely under human rule. Escape is necessary, which also holds the hope of regaining his lost memories...

The problem with Dark Moon is that it relies a bit too much on clichéd fantasy techniques: a mad king, a prodigal son, an amnesia plot device, and a corrupt human society — we've seen all this before. Pierce is on surer (and more interesting) ground when she deals with Tek's relationship with her mother, the mysterious backstory to Korr's past, and the different definition she makes of 'hero' in relation to Jan, who is more an information gatherer and society changer than a warrior or war hero. This is captured perfectly in the final chapters of the novel, when Jan is faced with the gryphon responsible for his separation from the herd and faces a crucial choice of life or death.

As usual Jah-Lila makes an intoxicating narrator, and despite its discrepancies Dark Moon is an essential part of the trilogy. Perhaps I've been too hard on Dark Moon, as it is an intriguing and well written book on its own terms... but you have much more to look forward to in The Son of Summer Stars.
Rebecca Fisher


book review Meredith Ann Pierce The Son of Summer Stars FirebringerThe Son of Summer Stars: "I'll Have the Truth If I Must Chase it to the World's Edge..."

Meredith Ann Pierce Firebringer review 1. Birth of the Firebringer 2. Dark Moon 3. The Son of Summer Stars In the last book in the Firebringer trilogy, we finally come to the event that the two previous books have been steadily building toward: the retaking of the unicorns' ancestral home from the treacherous wyverns. As the prophesied 'Firebringer', Prince Alijan is looked to as the means of regaining their Hallow Hills and Jan is certainly up to the challenge. Having finally made peace with the marauding gryphons, and finding happiness in his beloved Tek and their twin children, Jan has readied his tribe to march out to their homelands and do battle.

But there is one matter of business not yet dealt with — that of Korr, the mad once-king of the unicorns. Knowing his father to hold a terrible secret, Jan vows its discovery and leaves the herd under the power of Tek whilst he chases his father across plains and deserts. It is here the story splits into two in order to follow two separate narratives (much as it did in Dark Moon), that of Jan's journey, and that of Tek's actions against the wyverns. Some readers may be surprised at the course the story takes, for in many ways Tek becomes the central figure of the action whilst Jan simply watches from afar, but this I believe pays credit to Meredith Ann Pierce's innovative take on the typical fantasy genre.

To have a fantasy novel without human characters is unusual enough, but even more so is Pierce's treatment of Jan's role as the "hero" of the books. His destined role as Firebringer is not one of violence or conquering, but of enlightenment, understanding and peace — and in fact his close relationship with the goddess Alma puts an almost religious spin on what is expected of him. Throughout the trilogy, his greatest achievements have nothing to do with battles or warfare, but with learning and accepting others, forging friendships with enemies (in particular the gryphon Illishar), exploring new worlds and destroying barriers and superstition that stood between his tribe and other cultures. Jan's experiences widen even further here, as he integrates himself among the plain-dwelling unicorns and then amidst the magnificent dragons across the desert.

And of course there is the matter of Korr's secret. Although Korr himself sadly becomes a rather one-dimensional villain by this stage, the knowledge he carries certainly packs a punch. Perceptive readers will have undoubtedly unraveled Jan's mysterious past before the denouncement is made, (as well as the second twist that is still to come), but it effectively shakes up several relationships within the herd and brings new perspective to many of the actions and thoughts of individuals in the previous books. (Although Pierce makes an odd move in introducing another unicorn couple that seem to have the same dilemma as Jan and Tek — although to this couple, the situation is not a dilemma at all. However, since the problem is resolved in an entirely different way for Tek and Jan, one has to wonder why Pierce includes this other couple at all).

As usual, Pierce's strength is in her visual style and world-making techniques. We are treated to a beautiful retelling of the creation of the sun and moon by the goddess Alma, as well as the culture and lifestyles of the plain dwelling unicorns. But Pierce outdoes herself in the creation of the Smoking Mountains and the lives of the dragons that dwell there — it is imaginative writing at its very best. As for characterisation, Jan and Tek are as strong as ever, as is the mystical Jah-Lila, who also acts as the narrator of the story. Sadly Dagg and Ryvenna are relegated to the background and an interesting bond that grows between Jan's little sister Lell and the proud Illishar is established, but not taken anywhere. However Jan's mother Ses — who has been a mere cipher in previous books — is now given a poignant and memorable story of her own.

The Firebringer trilogy is not Pierce's best (that honour belongs to the Darkangel trilogy) but it stands as a beautifully written fantasy series that transcends the standard expectations of the genre. Especially relevant is Pierce's treatment of the unicorns themselves; in a world of cutesy portrayals, tacky figurines and various shades of the colour pink, Pierce gives the unicorns back some of their past dignity — as noble, fierce and even dangerous creatures, not as "My Little Pony" version. —Rebecca Fisher

Stand-alone novel:

The Woman Who Loved Reindeer — (1985) Young adult. Publisher: From the YA fantasy book reviews Meredith Ann Pierce The Woman Who Loved Reindeerauthor of the Darkangel Trilogy comes an epic romance, in the tradition of The Clan of the Cave Bear, about a young woman's love for a coldhearted shape-shifter.


YA fantasy book reviews Meredith Ann Pierce The Woman Who Loved ReindeerThe Woman Who Loved Reindeer

Set in a prehistoric fantasy setting of ice and snow, The Woman Who Loved Reindeer refers to its two main characters: the young Caribou and the child she names Reindeer. As someone who experiences prophetic dreams, Caribou lives alone until her sister-in-law brings to her a golden-haired child. Claiming that it is not her husband Visjna's child (Caribou's brother), Branja begs her to take in the child before Visjna returns from the season-long hunt and so that the child's true father cannot come to claim him.

Caribou is initially disdainful of such a request, but the tiny infant soon warms her heart. Due to his love of the reindeer herds, she names him after them, and goes about raising him to the best of his ability. But soon it becomes clear that he is no ordinary child. After a terrifying run-in with a golden reindeer that results in her brother's death, Caribou begins to notice more and more abnormalities about him: he neither cries nor laughs, bleeds golden blood, has inhuman reflections, and cannot understand the concept of love. But Caribou loves him deeply, and when she begins to suspect he is one of the spirit "daimons," she is terrified that she will lose him forever. When the seasons change, he takes reindeer form in order to travel with the herds beyond the dangerous Burning Plains and the Lands of the Broken Snow.

But Caribou's lands are in jeopardy. A range of natural disasters threatens the people. Having never been particularly close to them, Caribou is prepared to depart with Reindeer to safer lands — but years of service as a wisewoman make her sympathetic to those that come to her for help. She convinces Reindeer to lead all those who want to leave on the perilous journey to safety, and with her guiding dreams she leads her people onwards. But throughout the trek Caribou deals with an ongoing pain: whether or not Reindeer can come to love her, and whether she can trust him to fulfill his promise.

The Woman Who Loved Reindeer is another wonderful story from Meredith Ann Pierce, whose beautiful language, meaningful stories and rich themes make for essential reading. Her landscapes are wonderfully invoked, with everything from the languages to the details of clothing and utensils described to make the entire setting rich and realistic. Her use of real folklore (most of which is Scandinavian and Nordic), including daimons, trollwomen, sea-maids and Firekings, helps to create a sense of resonance and the feeling that this is a “real” part of the world's mythology.

Which is interesting since, in terms of plot, it has several Biblical echoes — in particular Noah's Ark and the story of Moses. Caribou's people are driven from their homes by natural disasters (like the flood) and forced on a long journey to safety and freedom, which at one stage involves a land-bridge rising above the waters (like the parting of the Red Sea). Caribou is a wise and determined leader throughout, disciplining those that deserve it, encouraging the unfaithful, and seeing through her promise no matter what the costs.

Some things don't quite gel together: the move from a mother/son relationship to lovers between Reindeer and Caribou is never quite drawn out or explored properly (surprising considering the changing feelings of love is the main theme — in fact the very title — of the book) and a second love interest is introduced only to be pushed to the side. And we never really learn anything conclusive about Branja's fate. But for any fans of fantasy, storytelling, or Meredith Ann Pierce, this is a must-read.
Rebecca Fisher


You can support FanLit by purchasing books (or anything else) through our Amazon links. Or donate.
© 2007-2012   Fantasy Literature   
The FTC wants you to know that we often receive free review copies from publishers.
  







1 FREE Audiobook from Audible





Admin