previous fantasy author

David & Leigh Eddings

1931-
2009
Reviewed by
Bill, Kat, Angus
next fantasy author
David Eddings fantasy authorDavid Eddings grew up near Seattle, in the Puget Sound area. In 1962, he married Judith Leigh Schall. He worked as a sales clerk at Boeing, a college English teacher, and served in the US Army. His first novel, the adventure High Hunt, debuted in 1973. His fantasy career began in 1982 with Pawn of Prophecy. He eventually published 27 novels. Eddings acknowledged that his wife helped write all of his novels, and her name began appearing on his works in the 1990s. Leigh Eddings died in 2007. Here's a website devoted to David and Leigh Eddings and here is SFWA's announcement of David Eddings' death in 2009.
View reader rating & comments about this author
Click covers for publication dates & formats (including audio & Kindle).
We post new fantasy book reviews almost daily!

The Belgariad — (1982-1998) Young adult. Publisher: It all begins with the theft of the Orb that for so long protected the West from an evil god. As long as the Orb was at Riva, the prophecy went, its people would be safe from this corrupting power. Garion, a simple farm boy, is familiar with the legend of the Orb, but skeptical in matters of magic. Until, through a twist of fate, he learns not only that the story of the Orb is true, but that he must set out on a quest of unparalleled magic and danger to help recover it. For Garion is a child of destiny, and fate itself is leading him far from his home, sweeping him irrevocably toward a distant tower — and a cataclysmic confrontation with a master of the darkest magic.

David Eddings The Belgariad: Pawn of Prophecy, Queen of Sorcery, Magician's Gambit, Castle of Wizardry, Enchanter's End GameDavid Eddings The Belgariad: Pawn of Prophecy, Queen of Sorcery, Magician's Gambit, Castle of Wizardry, Enchanter's End GameDavid Eddings The Belgariad: Pawn of Prophecy, Queen of Sorcery, Magician's Gambit, Castle of Wizardry, Enchanter's End GameDavid Eddings The Belgariad: Pawn of Prophecy, Queen of Sorcery, Magician's Gambit, Castle of Wizardry, Enchanter's End GameDavid Eddings The Belgariad: Pawn of Prophecy, Queen of Sorcery, Magician's Gambit, Castle of Wizardry, Enchanter's End Game

book review David Eddings The BelgariadThe Belgariad

Back before David Eddings became a shampoo-rinse-repeat sort of author, churning out the same old storylines and character types, there was the original Belgariad series, which remains by far his best work.

The premise is an old stand-by — farmboy discovers he’s not who he thought he was and, along with a band of helpers, goes on a quest to stop the world’s destruction/domination by the evil one. But Eddings manages to breathe a lot of life into the archetypical plot. His characters are gradually revealed throughout the series to have hidden layers of complexity, his main character, Garion, grows throughout the series, the tone darkens and deepens as one goes on, the world tour is detailed and interesting, the plot quick moving, and there is a great deal of humor laced throughout, often in the form of great character banter.

The Belgariad remains one of the better series to have come out, and in fact the formula worked so well that Eddings basically decided to use it again and again and again. Personally I found the repetition in later series grew too tiresome to tolerate, but none of that diluted the first joy that came with reading The Belgariad. It’s not as strong in its depth or literary creation as some others, but sometimes fun is enough. —Bill   Comments


David Eddings Pawn of Prophecy book reviewPawn of Prophecy: Juvenile

David Eddings The Belgariad: Pawn of Prophecy, Queen of Sorcery, Magician's Gambit, Castle of Wizardry, Enchanter's End GameI read Pawn of Prophecy as an adult, a few years ago. I had heard great things about it, so I was disappointed after reading it. The plot is typical "orphan boy saves the world" fantasy, the description is weak, the dialogue is often silly (humor is a focus, and much of the dialogue is funny — but it's not realistic). The pace is rapid, however, and I flew through the book in one day.

The Belgariad would be just right for a teenager (so I give it 3 stars), but not for an adult who's looking for something deeper to savor. —Kat   Comments

The Malloreon — (1985-1991) Sequel to The Belgariad. Publisher: Garion has slain the evil God Torak and is now the King of Riva. The prophecy has been fulfilled–or so it seems. For there is a dire warning, as a great evil brews in the East. Now Garion once again finds himself with the fate of the world resting on his shoulders. When Garion’s infant son is kidnapped by Zandramas, the Child of Dark, a great quest begins to rescue the child. Among those on the dangerous mission are Garion and his wife, Queen Ce’Nedra, and the immortal Belgarath the Sorcerer and his daughter, Polgara. They must make their way through the foul swamps of Nyissa, then into the lands of the Murgos. Along the way, they will face grave dangers — captivity, a horde of demons, a fatal plague — while Zandramas plots to use Garion’s son in a chilling ritual that will make the Dark Prophecy supreme...

David Eddings The Malloreon: Guardians of the West, Kings of the Murgos, Demon Lord of Karanda, Sorceress Darshiva, The Seeress of KellDavid Eddings The Malloreon: Guardians of the West, Kings of the Murgos, Demon Lord of Karanda, Sorceress Darshiva, The Seeress of KellDavid Eddings The Malloreon: Guardians of the West, Kings of the Murgos, Demon Lord of Karanda, Sorceress Darshiva, The Seeress of KellDavid Eddings The Malloreon: Guardians of the West, Kings of the Murgos, Demon Lord of Karanda, Sorceress Darshiva, The Seeress of KellDavid Eddings The Malloreon: Guardians of the West, Kings of the Murgos, Demon Lord of Karanda, Sorceress Darshiva, The Seeress of Kell
Available for download at Audible.com

Books related to The Belgariad and The Malloreon —
David Eddings Belgarath the Sorcerer, Polgara, David and Leigh Eddings The Rivan CodexDavid Eddings Belgarath the Sorcerer, Polgara, David and Leigh Eddings The Rivan CodexDavid Eddings Belgarath the Sorcerer, Polgara the Sorceress, David and Leigh Eddings The Rivan Codex

fantasy book reviews David Eddings The MalloreonThe Malloreon

Take the plot from The Belgariad, add in the same characters, plus a couple of new ones that look strangely similar to ones in The Belgariad, and you have The Malloreon. Instead of chasing the Orb, the gang is chasing Garion and Ce'Nedra's son.

This is a quest type of fantasy, and the same things that made The Belgariad so enjoyable are here: interesting characters and a humourous banter that makes for a quick read. The pace is fast. The difficulty is this: this is the same story as The Belgariad. The humourous banter is starting to get tired, and some of the jokes are recycled.

The characters stopped developing at the end of The Belgariad, except for the new ones, which show some personal development, but development that is totally out of context with their background and surroundings.

David Eddings's
style is light and quick. These are not books that one will ever get bogged down in. They are also not books that require a great deal of brain power to process. They are a light read, and due to the repetition of the previous series, this is getting a little boring, like a sit-com in its third season. I would gladly suggest these books and their predecessors to anyone 12 and up. There are no sex scenes, though there are definitely suggestions of sex, and the violence is not the stronger stuff that we see in fantasy today.

I am somewhat indifferent to these books. When I read them, I looked forward to them because I had loved The Belgariad so much. However, The Malloreon is just more of the same. It is virtually identical so, in the words of B.B. King, "the thrill is gone".

In conclusion, if you loved The Belgariad and need more of Eddings and these characters, then read this series. If you read The Belgariad and were satisfied, stop now. You would do better with a re-read of the original. —Angus   Comments

The Elenium — (1989-1991) Set in a different world than The Belgariad and The Malloreon.
Publisher: Sparhawk, Pandion Knight, and Queen's Champion have returned to Elenia after ten years of exile, only to find young Queen Ehlanda trapped in a block of ensorcelled crystal. As Sparhawk sets out to find a cure for Ehlana, he discovers that only he can defeat the evil plots that threaten her rule...

David Eddings THe Elenium: The Diamond Throne, The Ruby Knight, The Sapphire RoseDavid Eddings THe Elenium: The Diamond Throne, The Ruby Knight, The Sapphire RoseDavid Eddings THe Elenium: The Diamond Throne, The Ruby Knight, The Sapphire Rose
Available for download at Audible.com

fantasy book reviews David Eddings The Elenium The Diamond Throne, The Ruby Knight, The Sapphire RoseThe Elenium

I loved how The Elenium started. Sparhawk has to be the best character David Eddings has ever imagined. I thought, with the first book of this trilogy, that this series was a real departure from the world of Belgarath, Garion and Polgara.

The story starts as the publisher indicates, and it quickly becomes a quest for a mystical jewel that is buried somewhere. A cast of characters develops, and they go looking for the thing. However, this is where disappointment sets in. Though the characters in these books are different, the banter is the same, the narrative is almost pure dialogue, and after a while, you can't tell which character is speaking.

The pace is the typical Eddings speed, due to the formulaic plot and due to the simple prose. The characterization is hollow, and there is very little development. There could have been, especially with the bad guy Annias, but that opportunity was horribly squandered. Ages 12 and up could easily read these books, but they are a little darker than the earlier Eddings fare, so I will say 14.

I got very bored, by the end. This was more of the same for Eddings, and it was particularly disappointing after the The Diamond Throne started with so much promise. He lost half a star for that from this reviewer. Not terrible books, by any stretch, but neither are they very good.
Angus   Comments

The Tamuli — (1992-1994) Sequel to The EleniumPublisher: Danger stalked Queen Ehlana's realm. When an ambassador from the far-off Tamul Empire begged for help, Sparhawk, Ehlana's champion and Prince Consort, was the Emperor's last hope. For surely the knight who had killed the evil God Azash could prevail against the terror in Tamul. But waiting for him was a glittering court seething with corruption, treachery — and the greatest danger Sparhawk would ever face!

David Eddings The Tamuli: Domes of Fire, The Shining Ones, The Hidden CityDavid Eddings The Tamuli: Domes of Fire, The Shining Ones, The Hidden CityDavid Eddings The Tamuli: Domes of Fire, The Shining Ones, The Hidden City

fantasy book review David Eddings The TamuliDomes of Fire

David Eddings The Tamuli: Domes of Fire, The Shining Ones, The Hidden CityI could not bring myself to finish Domes of Fire. I stopped somewhere towards the end and thought "why am I wasting my time?" This book is another repeat of the Eddings "gather a group of characters and send them on a long journey" formula, and I just could not do it again.

I can't give a synopsis, because I didn't finish it, but I don't really need to. The plot is the same as everything else that Eddings had written up to the time that this series was done. The narrative is almost pure dialogue with no description at all, and the dialogue is repetitive beyond belief. I got the strong impression that Eddings really was milking his name for all it was worth, because there was nothing redeeming about Domes of Fire at all. Sparhawk even stopped being Sparhawk. The characters just started to run together in a gluey, non-distinctive mass, and I could not go further.

Do not read these books unless you are a die-hard David Eddings fan and you have a particularly forgiving heart. —Angus   Comments

The Dreamers — (2003-2006) Publisher: While most continents float freely on the face of Mother Sea, the Land of Dhrall survives anchored by the will of the Gods. AllGods, Elder and Younger, share the people and the land of Dhrall equally. But the one place they never enter is The Wasteland: a barren and hideous wilderness ruled by the Vlagh-a god-like creature whose young are evil spawn. Now, as the Elder Gods are about to transfer their power to the Younger Gods, the Vlagh plans to take advantage of their weakened state and neutralize them, eventually conquering the world. To do so, it is breeding a terrible force borne of monsters and demons. But one ray of hope shines through the darkness: four children called the Dreamers. They alone hold the power to change the course of history... and stop the Vlagh in its quest for total world domination.

David Eddings The Dreamers: The Elder Gods, The Treasured One, Crystal Gorge, The Younger GodsDavid Eddings The Dreamers: The Elder Gods, The Treasured One, Crystal Gorge, The Younger GodsDavid Eddings The Dreamers: The Elder Gods, The Treasured One, Crystal Gorge, The Younger GodsDavid Eddings The Dreamers: The Elder Gods, The Treasured One, Crystal Gorge, The Younger Gods

Stand-alone novel:

The Redemption of Althalus — (2000) Publisher: It would be sheer folly to try to conceal the true nature of Althalus, for his flaws are the stuff of legend. He is, as all men know, a thief, a liar, an occasional murderer, an outrageous braggart, and a man devoid of even the slightest hint of honor. Yet of all the men in the world, it is Althalus, unrepentant rogue and scoundrel, who will become the champion of humanity in its desperate struggle against the forces of an ancient god determined to return the universe to nothingness. On his way to steal The Book from the House at the End of the World, Althalus is confronted by a cat — a cat with eyes like emeralds, the voice of a woman, and the powers of a goddess. She is Dweia, sister to The Gods and a greater thief even than Althalus. She must be: for in no time at all, she has stolen his heart. And more. She has stolen time itself. For when Althalus leaves the House at the End of the World, much wiser but not a day older than when he'd first entered it, thousands of years have gone by. But Dweia is not the only David Eddings THe Redemption of Althalusone able to manipulate time. Her evil brother shares the power, and while Dweia has been teaching Althalus the secrets of The Book, the ancient God has been using the dark magic of his own Book to rewrite history. Yet all is not lost. But only if Althalus, still a thief at heart, can bring together a ragtag group of men, women, and children with no reason to trust him or each other.


David Eddings The Redemption of Althalus fantasy book reviewThe Redemption of Althalus

The Redemption of Althalus
was almost as bad as Domes of Fire (see my review above). I read it because I thought that maybe David Eddings got better. Unfortunately, it was more of the same. That’s the end of my review. Otherwise, I’ll just be repeating myself.
Angus   Comments

To comment, login with Google, Twitter, Yahoo, Open ID, etc (bottom left or top right of your screen).

Discount Gold OfferSupport FanLit by purchasing books (and other items) through our Amazon links. Or donate.
© 2007-2010   Fantasy Literature   
The FTC wants you to know that we often receive free review copies from publishers.
Follow FanLit on Twitter  Friend FanLit




Admin