previous fantasy author

Cassandra Clare

Reviewed by Terry Weyna
and Marion Deeds
next fantasy author
Cassandra Clare
Cassandra Clare
writes young adult urban fantasy. She got her start writing Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings fan fiction as Cassandra Claire. Cassandra Clare's website. The Mortal Instruments Trilogy website.




Click covers to view available formats, including audio & Kindle.

The Mortal Instruments — (2007-2012) Young adult. Publisher: Their hidden world is about to be revealed... When fifteen-year-old Clary Fray heads out to the Pandemonium Club in New York City, she hardly expects to witness a murder — much less a murder committed by three teenagers covered with strange tattoos and brandishing bizarre weapons. Clary knows she should call the police, but it's hard to explain a murder when the body disappears into thin air and the murderers are invisible to everyone but Clary. Equally startled by her ability to see them, the murderers explain themselves as Shadowhunters: a secret tribe of warriors dedicated to ridding the earth of demons. Within twenty-four hours, Clary's mother disappears and Clary herself is almost killed by a grotesque demon. But why would demons be interested in ordinary mundanes like Clary and her mother? And how did Clary suddenly get the Sight? The Shadowhunters would like to know...

Cassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of GlassCassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of GlassCassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of GlassCassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of Glass 4. City of Fallen Angels Cassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of Glass 4. City of Fallen Angels 5. City of Lost Souls
Available for download at Audible.comClick here for audio download

Cassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of Glass 4. City of Fallen AngelsCity of Bones

Cassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of GlassI’m a huge fan of books that don’t let me go until I’ve reached the last page. Cassandra Clare’s City of Bones, the first in her Mortal Instruments series, is that kind of book. Ostensibly written for young adults, this is a novel that adults will enjoy just as much as teenagers, for all that the protagonist and her friends are high-school aged.

Clary and her friend Simon — not boyfriend, much as he’d like to claim that title — visit the Pandemonium Club in Manhattan, a borough away from their homes in Brooklyn. A cute boy with blue hair and bright green eyes catches Clary’s eye, and she watches him until a beautiful girl in a long white dress beckons him into a room marked “No Admittance.” She watches long enough to see two other boys following them, one of whom pulls a knife just before entering the room. Startled and scared, Clary sends Simon off to get a security guard and, ignoring his instructions to stay put, heads off to rescue the blue-haired boy.

Clary gets quite a surprise when she enters the room, but she gives one as well. She shouldn’t be able to see any of the occupants of the room, they tell her. The blue-haired boy is a demon, while the other three are Shadowhunters. When Jace, one of the Shadowhunters, kills the blue-haired boy, the boy disappears, returning “to his home dimension,” Jace explains. Jace is immediately suspicious that Clary might be more than the “mundane” she seems to be, especially when Simon returns with a bouncer and proves unable to see the Shadowhunters, just as they know should be the case.

Something is definitely up, Clary quickly learns, because the next day her mother is suddenly insisting that they are “going on vacation” for the rest of the summer. Clary rebels at this news, as she had a season’s worth of plans, including art lessons she’s already paid for. She storms out of their home when Simon arrives, and the two of them head for a coffeehouse for a poetry slam. And who should be there but Jace? Just as Jace is explaining to Clary that she needs to come with him to “the Institute,” Clary’s mom calls and warns her, clearly in terror, not to come home. Clary hears the sound of falling, a buzz of static, and a harsh, slithering noise before the connection is severed. Clary rushes home, finds her mother comatose, and runs into a huge, malignant spider demon, a Ravener — and that’s when Clary knows her life has changed forever.

Clary’s discoveries follow fast and furious from that point. Most importantly, she learns that she is not who and what she thought she was, but comes from a lineage she shares in common with Jace, his adoptive sister Isabelle, and his adoptive brother, Alec. The three take her in and try to figure out why she has been raised as a mundane — and to give her shelter, as she cannot return to her home and her mother’s good friend, Luke, has harshly told Clary he isn’t her father and she should stay away from him.

Clary is quickly immersed in a world of demons, vampires, werewolves and mages that she never knew existed, learning how to deal with an entirely new level of reality even while she searches for a way to bring her mother out of her coma. She learns that her father may not have been a man who died before she was born, but someone altogether different — and evil. Soon it becomes clear that she has talents neither she nor anyone else suspected, and a fate awaiting her that has nothing to do with the gentle life of an artist she had anticipated.

The action is nonstop, with characters the reader quickly comes to love in nearly constant peril. It seems almost no one is who he or she purports to be. And the problems Clary faces go far beyond her mother’s unexplained coma; they encompass the future of humankind. You’ll want to read all of the nearly 500 pages in one sitting, if you can, and once you’ve turned the last page, you’ll want to reach immediately for the next book in the series.

Cassandra Clare knows how to hold a reader’s attention, no matter the reader’s age. The themes are appropriate for teens, with most of the violence occurring offstage, except for the killing of demons, who are the baddest of bad guys. Clare manages to avoid profane language and yet still have her teenagers sound like teenagers, and while there are plenty of intimations of sexual attraction, there are no X or even R-rated scenes. I think my nearly 12-year-old nephew would call this book “Awesome!” — and I think I know what he’s getting for his birthday. —Terry Weyna


Cassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of Glass 4. City of Fallen AngelsCity of Fallen Angels

Cassandra Clare Mortal Instruments review 1. City of Bones 2. City of Ashes 3. City of Glass 4. City of Fallen AngelsWhen I finished City of Fallen Angels I was angry; not with Cassandra Clare, who created the Mortal Instruments series, but with the evil-doers who once again have come between Clary and her Shadowhunter boyfriend, Jace.

At the end of City of Glass, the Shadowhunters and the downworlders — vampires, faerie, and werewolves — banded together to stand against Clary’s arrogant and megalomaniacal Shadowhunter father Valentine in a cataclysmic battle. Clary used her newly discovered talent for the magical runes called Marks to defeat her father and bring Jace back from death. Her once-human friend Simon, who became a vampire while trying to help her, was safe, and Shadowhunters and downworlders were drawing up an Accord so that they could live together in peace and equality.

It seems that the war is not over after all.

City of Fallen Angels begins not with Clary and Jace, but with Simon, back in mundane New York City, trying to figure out how to live as a Daywalker (a vampire who can survive sunlight) and one with the Mark of Cain on his forehead, a curse that, paradoxically, protects Simon from everyone except God. Simon is soon approached by Camille, an ancient vampire who offers him a bargain. Simon is suspicious. He stalls Camille. His more immediate problem is how to break the news to his mother that he is a vampire. Simon has not fed on a live human being yet; he is subsisting on animal blood he is hiding in his closet, an inadequate solution. As if that weren’t enough, Simon is juggling two supernatural girlfriends; Isabelle, a Shadowhunter, and Maia, a werewolf. Clary, meanwhile, is helping prepare for her mother’s wedding, while the Shadowhunter Conclave is trying to determine who is murdering the rogue Shadowhunters who had joined Valentine’s Circle and leaving the bodies in areas meant to throw suspicion on downworlders.

Clare does a fine job of bringing new characters, such as Kyle and Camille, into the story, and she has cleverly knit in bits from The Clockwork Angel, in which Camille was introduced. The plot is formulaic at times, but Clare handles the formula well. One of the refreshing things about this series is that it has, in some respects, an ensemble cast. The book is as much Simon’s story as it is Jace and Clary’s. This allows Clare to cut away from Jace and Clary, which is good because Jace’s perpetual angst can get wearing, even though in this book the cause is not his own internal obsessing but an integral part of the plot.

By starting with Simon and his real-world difficulties, Clare also gives the book momentum. This doesn’t feel like a new start on a new trilogy; it is plausible that, even though our heroes have won a great victory, there would still be problems ahead.

The villain in this book is convincing, as Valentine was in the previous three, and the plot springs credibly from events in the earlier books. Clare does not paint the Shadowhunters as perfect, and when villains tell Simon that no matter how he helps the Shadowhunters they will never accept him, this is powerful because it is true. We see the casual bigotry of the demon fighters throughout these books, and we watch some of them wrestle with the meaning of power. This makes the struggles throughout the series more believable.

On a more superficial level, Clare has perfected post-modernist bantering, and her young characters never miss a good come-back line, a quip or a witty retort. This makes for enjoyable reading.

Structurally, Clare has a habit of telling the reader a bit too much sometimes, so that the other characters, who don’t know what we know, look a bit stupid. I think she does this to increase the suspense. Instead, it undercuts her characters. The ending of the book is also predictable, although I wasn’t particularly bothered by that. Perhaps the word I want is not “predictable” but “inevitable”; or perhaps I’m letting Clare off easy because I think she has left us with a great cliffhanger and set up all kinds of trouble for the future. Drama and mechanics only count for so much. The heart of any book, for me, is character. I like Simon and I want him to be happy. I care about Clary and Jace, and their problems have me worrying and waiting for the next volume. —Marion Deeds

 

The Infernal Devices — (2010-2012) Young adult. This series is a prequel to The Mortal Instruments. Publisher: Magic is dangerous — but love is more dangerous still. When sixteen-year-old Tessa Gray crosses the ocean to find her brother, her destination is England, the time is the reign of Queen Victoria, and something terrifying is waiting for her in London's Downworld, where vampires, warlocks and other supernatural folk stalk the gaslit streets. Only the Shadowhunters, warriors dedicated to ridding the world of demons, keep order amidst the chaos. Kidnapped by the mysterious Dark Sisters, members of a secret organization called The Pandemonium Club, Tessa soon learns that she herself is a Downworlder with a rare ability: the power to transform, at will, into another person. What's more, the Magister, the shadowy figure who runs the Club, will stop at nothing to claim Tessa's power for his own. Friendless and hunted, Tessa takes refuge with the Shadowhunters of the London Institute, who swear to find her brother if she will use her power to help them. She soon finds herself fascinated by — and torn between — two best friends: James, whose fragile beauty hides a deadly secret, and blue-eyed Will, whose caustic wit and volatile moods keep everyone in his life at arm's length... everyone, that is, but Tessa. As their search draws them deep into the heart of an arcane plot that threatens to destroy the Shadowhunters, Tessa realizes that she may need to choose between saving her brother and helping her new friends save the world... and that love may be the most dangerous magic of all.

Cassandra Clare The Infernal Devices 1. The Clockwork Angel 2. The Clockwork Prince 3. The Clockwork KingdomCassandra Clare The Infernal Devices 1. The Clockwork Angel 2. The Clockwork Prince 3. The Clockwork Kingdom
Available for download at Audible.comClick here for audio download
Book 3: The Clockwork Kingdom

Clockwork Angel

Cassandra Clare The Infernal Devices 1. The Clockwork Angel 2. The Clockwork Prince 3. The Clockwork KingdomAnd then comes the final test, the infallible touchstone of the seventh-rate: Ichor. It oozes out of severed tentacles, it beslimes tessellated pavements, bespatters bejeweled courtiers, and bores the bejesus out of everybody.
~Ursula K. Le Guin, From Elfland to Poughkeepsie

Cassandra Clare
stumbles straight out of the gate in Clockwork Angel. In the opening sentence... “ichor,” one of Ursula K. Le Guin’s perfect tests for bad fantasy. The opening sentence!

Can Clare recover? Yes, she can and does.

This is Clare’s second series about the Shadowhunters, human-angel hybrids who hunt down demons and other evil creatures, protecting mundane humanity. The Mortal Instruments series was set in contemporary New York. Clockwork Angel is set in London in the late 1870s, and is the first book of the Infernal Devices trilogy. Clare’s young adult audience will feel right at home here. The book is advertised as a prequel, and many of the last names, such as Herondale, will be familiar. A couple of characters from The Mortal Instruments turn up, reminding us that they are magical and thus long-lived.

Tess Gray, the young American who comes to London to find her brother and is immediately kidnapped by evildoers, is a smart and physically courageous heroine. She has magical powers of her own, but there is some confusion as to whether she is demon, partly demon, or something else entirely. Tess is an educated young woman who has read Dante’s Inferno and Shakespeare. In a nice homage, Clare names another character Charlotte Branwell, a nod to Charlotte Brontë, a best-selling author of Victorian times. (Brontë’s brother was named Branwell.) Surprisingly, Tess never comments to herself on this strange coincidence.

The configuration of young Shadowhunters mirrors the first three books; two young men and a woman. Tess’s love interest, Will, is another tortured bad-boy, which is a shame, since the sidekick character Jem is far more interesting. Clare always makes the girl Shadowhunter adversarial with her human main character, and Jessamine, a spoiled aristocrat who dislikes Shadowhunting, is no exception. The most interesting characters in the book are the humans Henry and Sophie. Several of the human attendants are lightly sketched in, as if they don’t really matter, and it soon becomes clear why.

Clare’s action sequences are vividly drawn. She renders London with a good blend of sensuous detail. Tess and Will often quote poetry to each other, and Tess compares situations around her to classic Victorian novels such as Jane Eyre, which encourages the curious reader to seek these books out for pleasure, not merely for classroom assignments. The plot is predictable, and things that are revealed as if they are surprises are not surprising at all, but the book maintains tension, and the jeopardy, faced first by Tess and later by her brother Nate, is convincing and dramatic.

The hardback edition has an exquisite cover, and the clockwork angel itself — yes, there is one — is a delightful mystery that still has not been solved by the book’s end. Fans of The Mortal Instruments will be pleased, and the almost-steampunk setting may draw in an even bigger audience. Perhaps some of them will look up the word “ichor” and realize that it probably isn’t the slime, goop or gunk that shoots out of the exploding demon in the book’s first sentence. —Marion Deeds


Cassandra Clare The Infernal Devices 1. The Clockwork Angel 2. The Clockwork Prince 3. The Clockwork KingdomClockwork Prince

Cassandra Clare The Infernal Devices 1. The Clockwork Angel 2. The Clockwork Prince 3. The Clockwork KingdomI’m giving Clockwork Prince by Cassandra Clare three stars, because it ably fulfills its function as the second book in the INFERNAL DEVICES series, but I didn’t enjoy it quite as much as I did Clockwork Angel. The writing is fine and the story moves well, but somehow our heroic characters just aren’t shown at their best in this volume.

After the debacle at the end of Clockwork Angel, Benedict Lightwood, patriarch of another Shadowhunter family, challenges Charlotte Branwell for control of the London Institute. His reasons are mostly couched in the language of sexism, but that doesn’t mean he’s wrong. Charlotte’s husband Henry is a distracted genius who has to be reminded to eat; the Shadowhunters who live in the Institute are underage and one of them, Will Herondale, has set a new standard for “loose cannon” behavior. Then there is Tessa, the heroine of these books. Tessa has powers that seem to be more demonic than angelic/Shadowhunter, even though it has been determined that she is not a warlock (actually, this is a large logic question for me). She has been told by the villain that she half Shadowhunter, half demon. Tessa is the target of Mortmain, the man who invented and controls the demon-powered mechanical men who are menacing the Shadowhunters. Is it really wise to let her live at the heart of the London Shadowhunter community?

Tessa remains the smart, honest and courageous girl we met in Clockwork Angel, and Sophie, the Branwells’ maid, emerges in this book as a strong and wise character too. Jessamine, the disaffected orphan of two Shadowhunters, behaves in a manner completely consistent with her character. Her actions, which drive large portions of the plot here, are completely plausible.

Will is the tortured bad-boy in this series, and in this book we discover the reason for his bad behavior. When Will was twelve, he opened a container that held a demon captive. The demon escaped, but not before cursing Will. It is this curse that has dictated Will’s abominable actions. This is an important part of the story, but Will focuses his energy on solving his own personal problem (finding the demon who cursed him) rather than helping Charlotte meet the time-limited test that has been set for her if she is to maintain control of the Institute. One problem with the book is that Clare does not evoke the “ticking clock” enough. Once, Jessamine mentions that they have only nine days of their two weeks left, but there is no other counting down, no increasing sense of urgency. This is mostly because the focus of the book is the love triangle between Tessa, Will and Jem.

The book takes us out of the environs of London into Yorkshire, as Tessa, Will and Jem pursue the history of Mortmain. The titular Clockwork Prince never appears directly in the book, but the reader learns a great deal about him and his motivation. I wish Clare had devoted a little more time to descriptions of Yorkshire, because her physical descriptions are so lovely. This part of the book gives us more information about Will. It was all interesting but I couldn’t shake the feeling that it was laying the foundation for the third book, not addressing the issues raised in this one.

Clare has mastered the spiraling-tension model of love triangles; an obstacle separates the couple, the obstacle is removed only to uncover a bigger obstacle, and so on. In this book, it really does seem that the death of a beloved character is the only way to remove the new obstacle between Will and Tessa. The bigger problem for me is that Jem, Will’s parabatai, is a much more interesting character and a better love interest than the self-centered Will.

The other small logic flaw is the issue of a “demon mark” on Tessa. Tessa has been carefully examined for a mark that would prove she is a warlock. All warlocks have a “mark.” Usually it’s green skin or slitted pupils like a cat’s, or in one case, tiny horns. Tessa has no unusual marks, except for the fact that her index fingers are nearly as long as her middle finger. Could this be a demon mark? Why hasn’t anyone commented on it?

For all these quibbles, Clare tells a suspenseful story. I felt bad that Charlotte and company resort to trickery and extortion at the end, rather than solving the mystery, but Benedict Lightwood is so arrogant that I only felt a little bad. The characters are strong and well-delineated; the dialogue is crisp and snappy; the misunderstanding between Henry and Charlotte about the nature of their marriage is believable. The book is filled with poetry, mostly Victorian (although a Shakespearean sonnet gets a nod), and Will and Tessa often discuss the novels of the time. This book does a good job of advancing the scheme of the Clockwork Prince, revealing more about Will’s background and developing the mystery of Tessa’s past. —Marion Deeds


You can support FanLit by purchasing books (or anything else) through our Amazon links. Or donate.
© 2007-2012   Fantasy Literature   
The FTC wants you to know that we often receive free review copies from publishers.
  







1 FREE Audiobook from Audible





Admin